3 ms·
"A good manager, who builds & runs a good team can achieve far more than any single great employee. There are no one man companies worth $1bn. It's appropriate
by nicoburns 11y ago
"A good manager, who builds & runs a good team can achieve far more than any single great employee.
There are no one man companies worth $1bn.
It's appropriate that manager compensation reflects this value for shareholders"
Is what the manager does really more valuable? Sure, the team wouldn't work without a great manager. But it also wouldn't work without great team members. All of those people are replaceable with someone of equal qualities, and not with someone else who isn't as good in some way.
Thus I think any claim that managers should be compensated more has to rest on the idea that management is more difficult (which is presumably true in some cases and not others, depending on what the team is doing).
Managers shouldn't be seen as leaders sitting above the team, they should be seen as a member of the team with a specific role focused on business objectives and ensuring that the others on the team's work is going smoothly.
- sgt101 11y agoI think it's interesting how little statistical or empiric information is around to underpin argument in this space. So, that said, I guess I am just going on experience when I say that good managers can make an average team into a good one and bad managers can turn great teams into poor ones. I think that the value added can be large and the value destroyed significant. Thinking about a team of 6 contributors and one manager six folks delivering at the differential good vs poor seems to me to be likely to be much greater than the whole value of one person who is delivering at "excellent". 2 * 6 * x > 10 *x ? Also 6 is a reasonable team size, but in reality I think very strong team managers tend to attract more staff and handle them efficiently up to much higher numbers (in the past I've been part of functional teams >14) Senior management (managers of managers) can have much greater multiplicative effects. Turning a poor manager into a good one (or getting rid of the so and so), helping good managers really shine, and setting the right agendas and behaviors (don't be a jerk, talk about your stuff, fess up fast) and most of all empowering people and getting them to believe in a future can make 100's of people go from delivering 0 value to delivering scores of millions in a few years.