2 ms·
And we can push the argument to the absurd. I can draw a little symbol on a post it, and that little symbol may mean something to me, it's a form of cipher. Now
by cm2187 11y ago
And we can push the argument to the absurd. I can draw a little symbol on a post it, and that little symbol may mean something to me, it's a form of cipher. Now can the court force me to tell them what this little symbol means, should I really go to jail if I don't?
The other thing is that although the 5th amendment is an American concept, I suppose there must be a provision against self incrimination in UK law. I can't be forced to testify against myself. In France I know this how it works, a defendant is entitled to lie or refuse to answer at his own trial. If we follow that logic I don't see how one can force someone to speak a password.
- caf 11y agoYes, the privilege against self-incrimination is part of the English common law (originally the defendant could not testify at all in common law courts!).