6 ms·
> She lost her health insurance because she exceeded the policy limits and had to skip her last chemo treatment. What in fucking hell is this? An insurance exi
by mschuster91 11y ago
> She lost her health insurance because she exceeded the policy limits and had to skip her last chemo treatment.
What in fucking hell is this? An insurance exists to protect people from going bankrupt due to health issues, not to screw people over when they're already in no position to fight.
How on earth is this legal?
- CydeWeys 11y agoIt's not legal anymore, thanks to Obamacare. This happened the year before that provision went into effect.
- edraferi 11y agoThanks Obama!
- ridgeguy 11y agoI think there's explanatory power in remembering that private, for-profit insurance companies have as their corporate priority maximization of shareholder value. Protecting people from bankruptcy due to medical expenses is not a corporate goal.
- cb18 11y agoIf word gets out that a company's insurance is kinda shitty, they're going to find themselves with fewer customers going forward, which is not good for shareholder value. Nickle and diming on a claim isn't where shareholder value comes from, but rather providing a good product that does what it is meant to do.
- Retra 11y agoThat's not really a factor when your employer is the one choosing your insurance providers.
- darpa_escapee 11y agoProve that to the shareholders and executives.
- DanBC 11y ago> If word gets out that a company's insurance is kinda shitty Does any insurance company have a good reputation? Is there any insurance company that doesn't have an InsuranceCompanySUCKS.com page?
- refurb 11y agoThat's true of any company (that profit is the goal). Yet, amazingly many companies do a great job, because happy customers = profit!
- rlonstein 11y ago> corporate priority maximization of shareholder value. I'm not sure if you're commenting on their observed behavior or their actual obligation. It would be good to put the phrase away since it's usually short-hand for a moral judgement on short-term focus (be sure, I'm not arguing either way here though I do hold an opinion). The fact is there is no legal duty for a corporation to maximize shareholder value, a couple of links: https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2012/06/26/the-shareholder-value-myth/ https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2012/06/26/the-shareholder-v... https://www.salon.com/2012/04/04/the_shareholder_fallacy/ https://www.salon.com/2012/04/04/the_shareholder_fallacy/
- cmdrfred 11y ago> maximization of shareholder value. Attempting to get the ACA repealed by posting lower than average profits (while running less efficiently, not taking all the tax breaks available, and increasing executive compensation and perks) would certainly maximize shareholder value long term.
- rdtsc 11y agoIt's un-American though. It somehow feels too socialistic to just have ulimited healthcare support. > An insurance exists to protect people from going bankrupt due to health issues On paper, in reality it is to feed the mouths of health care insurance workers. The level of rhetoric regarding how nationalized healtcare takes away our choice and freedom and how it brings socialism and doom to our country has always baffled me. I watched the whole thing unfold for many years now. And it wasn't just one or two people here and there, it is whole segments of population who opposed a single payer system, the industry opposed it, so that was thrown out early on. You'd imagine we were talking about forcing people to sell their first born children or even worse confiscating their property. There were suggestions (even here on HN) of proposing some alternative back to the 1800's free market utopian version ("let's go back to the pure and glorious golden age of free markets" etc). And that would be have been interesting to see and discus if we talked about some experimental new economic system or social order. But we were talking about a basic thing that exists and existed for decades in dozens of other developed countries, which have longer living, healthier, happier people.
- mirimir 11y ago> On paper, in reality it is to feed the mouths of health care insurance workers. Workers? I doubt that. More like executives.
- rdtsc 11y agoI meant it to be both, the institution as a whole. The idea of "oh but what about the jobs of everyone in insurance company, think of the admin assistants and poor call center workers" has been presented before as an argument against a single payer system.
- mirimir 11y agoThe workers would probably get paid at least as much, handling claims for the government health system.
- ams6110 11y agoIt is legal because there was a limit defined in the policy. No insurance is open-ended, sky-is-the-limit. In many cases (e.g. auto, home, business) the limit is capped at the value of the assets that are insured. In other cases (liability) there is a defined dollar limit. My homeowners and auto policies have liability insurance but there is a limit. If I caused a traffic accident with signifcant property damage and multiple serious injuries, my liability insurance limit would likely be exceeded. Health insurance has limits as well, even with the recent changes that the ACA introduced. The ACA removes limits on "essential health benefits" but who decides what those are? Hint: Not you. If there were no limits on health insurance there would be little backpressure to ensure that care provided is worth paying for, or to put it another way, has real benefit. You'd have hopeless cases on life support forever, or unrealistically expensive treatment of conditions for which there is no real hope. Sad as it is, some health problems can't be fixed, and at some point you need to admit that and stop throwing money away. One more chemo treatment would very likely have made little difference in the outcome for this woman.
- rsync 11y ago"If there were no limits on health insurance there would be little backpressure to ..." Also, it wouldn't be insurance. People think that insurance is "something that I want that does nice things for me". It's not. Insurance is a math problem and it has a precise answer. If you go beyond that answer it doesn't work. Either you're getting screwed or the (hapless) insurance company goes out of business.
- jfoutz 11y agoThe math problem is tricky in a lot of ways though. For example, the rate the insurance company pays doctors is different than the retail rate. Lots of people don't realize this. It also brings up two pretty interesting questions. One, could the patient have covered the last session at the price insurance companies pay? And two, does the insurance company run down that upper limit based on the amount they're billed, or the amount they pay? There's another interesting policy question. Insurance, flat out, can't pay for everything. So, given that they have a pool of money, do you allocate that toward the least sick people? That's probably a better approach to more total years of survival. ensure the healthiest 50% (or whatever) get excellent care, and let the rest go. Alternatively, do you triage and spend the the money on people who have a slim chance of survival, making the heroic rescue day after day? I find that policy decision horrifying. I honestly have no idea how they pick. But it's pretty obvious, somebody getting chemo means 100 other people aren't getting, for example, cholesterol medication. I'll agree it's just an equation. but man, i'd love to see those tables showing years of human life saved based on condition and treatment. Just to add a touch more cynicism, should those years be weighted based on economic productivity? Would we be better off with 10 more years of Steve Jobs or 10 more years of Grandma? My gut says Grandma, but... it's just an equation.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoInsurance which covers some things is better than no insurance. Caps reduce the cost. You might as well ask why low end processed cheese ($4.50/lb, not very tasty) is legal - why not ban it and force everyone to eat delicious artisinal asiago ($12.99/lb, mouth wateringly good) instead? Won't someone think of the poor people who aren't spending enough on dinner?
- true_religion 11y agoActually even NHS has a limit for the amount they'll spend on your treatment over time. It's rare to hit it, but any system that's trying to allocate the scare resource of medical treatment will have to stop a minority of very sick people from receiving all the resources.
- refurb 11y agoGood point. Even if your health insurance is public, someone, somewhere is figuring out what can and can't be paid for. One of the reasons other countries spend less on healthcare, compared to the US, is that they just don't pay for certain things (drugs, procedures, etc). The US is a bit more lax when it comes to this and that results in higher costs.
- sinxoveretothex 11y agoIn Canada, we have a drug insurance tax (in Quebec at least, I'm unsure if this is a federal thing) so we clearly pay for drugs. I don't know the extent of what we do pay for, but surgeries and most everything is paid for by taxes. Even breast reduction is covered if a doctor judges that it's for health reasons.
- evgen 11y agoYou pay for production. All of the research cost and business risk in going to market with the drug in the first place is paid by Americans. You're welcome.
- teh64 11y agoSource? Because one of the articles if found says only 44% of global medical research is done by America (in terms of funding): https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/news/story/4233/u.s.-slipping-as-global-leader-in-medical-research.aspx https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/news/story/4233/u.s.-slipping...
- DanBC 11y ago
- VonGuard 11y agoWelcome to the United States.
- fpoling 11y agoUnfortunately realistic insurance claim models show that without a policy limit the insurance company will be bankrupt eventually with 100% probability. So a limit must exist or the would be no insurance business.