3 ms·
You agreed that much of the medical spending which insurance pays for is not a necessity. So while health care costs are increasing quickly, they do not meet yo
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
You agreed that much of the medical spending which insurance pays for is not a necessity. So while health care costs are increasing quickly, they do not meet your criteria for being a necessity.
Increasing the marginal cost of medicine to the consumer is not the same thing as increasing unit costs.
Consider a $100 pill; if a customer has gold plated plans with no copay, the marginal cost of the pill is $0. If the customer has a plan with a $101 deductible, the marginal cost is $100. In both cases the unit cost is $100.
Switching a customer from first dollar to high deductible coverage will cause the consumer to consume less medicine, but will have no (direct) effect whatsoever on the unit cost. This lowers aggregate costs directly (since consumers consume less), which in turn reduces demand and indirectly lowers unit costs.
Also, note that you originally claimed health insurance costs went up 15% / year. Now you claim health care unit costs go up 15% / year. Which is it?
- jbooth 17y agoSigh. How many ways can I put this? Having health insurance is a necessity if I don't want to continually be one bad day away from bankruptcy. The unit cost of insuring a person has increased 15% a year all decade. If "much of what it pays for" isn't a necessity then that's just more evidence of how broken the system is. Your high deductible approach is one way to tackle the problem however it has the problem of disincentivizong preventative care, so we might get a lot more 20k emergency room trips instead of 300$ physicals -- and have a less healthy population, to boot. But it might also be a component of a plan that worked. I'd note that "most capitalistic" does not always mean "most effective" -- just usually, for normal markets. Otherwise we'd all take capitalist cabs to work every day instead of the socialist subway :)