32 ms·
Ok, first I am always in awe of people who have the skill to disassemble, fix at the component level, and reassemble modern electronics. I am also not surprised
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Ok, first I am always in awe of people who have the skill to disassemble, fix at the component level, and reassemble modern electronics. I am also not surprised that both the independent repair folks get told they aren't as good as Apple, and that Apple isn't doing anything more or less magical in their repairs.
I do however take a bit of issue with generalizing from one or two instances. Just as there are "bad" independent repair techs, there are no doubt "bad" Apple repair techs. And bad techs make sloppy repairs, period. The reality is that the "best" your electronic device will be, is likely just after it comes off the assembly line and passes QA, that entire assembly process and the components used are tightly controlled so you get the best possible outcome. Rework inevitably it hard on components, traces, and often has to use materials that differ from the ones usable in the original manufacture.
- ams6110 11y agoI doubt that Apple refurbs the devices themselves. They are most likely sent over to China and repaired in a sweatshop by workers inhaling solder and adhesive fumes all day.
- ratsmack 11y agoApple should maintain a standard of quality control. If this is representative of that control, then what she is saying is correct in that their work is not representative of what they espouse.
- x0x0 11y agoRight, but it's either apple policy to repair and resell water damaged boards or not. I can't believe a line level tech is going to make that call contrary to policy. Or care really; I doubt his or her salary is affected either way on the call whether a board is salvageable or not.