3 ms·
Give the average person money without structure, instruction or necessity and they cease to be productive in any sense of the word I don't think you have evide
by barrkel 11y ago
Give the average person money without structure, instruction or necessity and they cease to be productive in any sense of the word
I don't think you have evidence to make a statement this strong. We have no idea what would happen because it's never been done before. I think you're projecting an idea you have of people on the margins of productive society onto society as a whole, and I think this is a fundamental mistake.
People are status-seeking - that's what people in groups do. Capitalist consumer society measures status in a large part based on how much money you can spend. Remove money from the equation and a substitute marker for status will be found. It could be power, art, popularity, charity, science - anything. What it is we don't know, but it will certainly be something.
- scottLobster 11y agoPerhaps. I'll admit most of my "evidence" is anecdotal, and I've read the studies about giving free money to tribes in Kenya and the Cherokee and how it greatly elevated them in general, although both studies come with serious caveats. My concern is what a long-term infusion would do, and I'm not aware of any research that's even approached that. Give someone who was desperately poor more money and sure it will elevate them, for a time, in large part IMO because they are aware the infusion is temporary and they try to make the most of it (whatever that means to them). Make the infusion constant enough to be taken for granted, and IMO there's be a lot less drive to be productive. When you have food, water, shelter, reasonable comfort and entertainment, what's the drive? Sure some will be motivated by personal passion, fascination, sense of exploration, etc just as they are today. In fact that probably describes most of the posters on this board, and I'd argue that more likely projective argument here is that the AVERAGE person would care about things like art, charity, science, even power and popularity. I don't know where you went to school, and I'm certain this varies from culture to culture, but in my experience the vast majority of students below the post-grad level are in school for two reasons: 1. Someone told them to go and 2. They want a job with a snowball's chance in hell of earning decent money. Those strongly motivated by something other than necessity are few and far between.
- TheCowboy 11y agoI think the continued claim that this has "never been done before" is often ignoring interesting situations that might provide some caution against blindly pursuing basic income. One could look to Saudi Arabia, flush in oil income, and unable to staff many of its important industries without importing foreign labor and expertise. It can be argued that maybe the culture there has been problematic, where young men grow up viewing it as beneath them to work. I think there's a large chance that basic income is implemented in some form, but it's not guaranteed as a successful policy. I would also like examples like these to inform any discussion and eventual policy that becomes implemented. There are other economic tools and levers that should be exercised today that could make basic income unnecessary or buy us some time to get it implemented correctly, but prevailing politics don't allow this.
- kwhitefoot 11y ago> We have no idea what would happen because it's never been done before. Untrue. Granted not on the scale that we should try, but it has been tried at least twice at small town scale in the US and once in Canada. The Canadian study was re-analysed relatively recently: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mincome