3 ms·
He was against Stalinism. But he fought in a Trotskyist militia. With criticisms, yes. But he took up arms with communists. Which is why I always find it quit
by cmrdporcupine 11y ago
He was against Stalinism.
But he fought in a Trotskyist militia. With criticisms, yes. But he took up arms with communists.
Which is why I always find it quite amusing when libertarians and conservatives use Animal Farm and 1984 as support in their arguments. Orwell would break no bread with them; he was a socialist of a revolutionary bent.
- pessimizer 11y ago> But he fought in a Trotskyist militia. With criticisms, yes. But he took up arms with communists. That's why he was against Communism. His experience with the Communists and with being a Communist.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoCitation needed.
- vidarh 11y agoHe was against Stalinism and the views of the British Communist Party (which were Stalinists). But he as late as 1946 pronounced himself a supporter of democratic socialism (in "Why I Write"), which can mean anything from the left wing of social democracy to left communists. In other writings he demonstrated a lot of Trotskyist influences. E.g. a lot of the criticism of Stalinism in Animal Farm is heavily incfluenced by Trotskyism.
- cmrdporcupine 11y agoThe Animal Farm is basically Trotsky's "The Revolution Betrayed" done with animals.
- AimHere 11y agoAs well as the point made by the others, part of why he opposed (big C) Communism was that they were counterrevolutionary and suppressed the actual socialist revolution that was happening in Spain at the time. In short, the Stalinists were too right-wing for him. Homage to Catalonia does make that clear. There's no sense, in any of Orwell's later writing, that he renounced socialism and plenty that affirmed his socialist ideas. Orwell stated in one of those works (Why I Write, 1946), that every word he wrote since 1936 was for democratic socialism, and the ending of Animal Farm, for instance, ultimately shows the communist pigs being no different from the capitalist humans (something that the CIA latched onto when they financed the 1948 animated film version, and so they had the ending changed).