3 ms·
Does Stress Speed Up Evolution?
- imaginenore 11y agoSounds like he is confusing individual organism adaptation with species evolution. Both exist.
- astazangasta 11y agoExactly this. Why would humans have a stress response that generates somatic mutation? It makes no sense. Also strategies that apply to organisms with large effective population sizes that expand clonally (bacteria) won't apply to humans. Also also, while mutator phenotypes might be useful under stress, once the stress is gone they quickly become disadvantageous and disappear. Deleterious mutation load has to go somewhere: the usual avenue is death in asexual organisms.
- Someone 11y agoLike you I agree with the grandfather post, but "Why would humans have a stress response that generates somatic mutation?" could easily be answered with "because it tends to work" because that is what drives evolution. I can make up a (at least at first sight) plausible explanation, too. Assume a constant energy budget and increased demand when under stress. Then, when running out of reserves, some other energy consumer must be cut down on. Things that only have real value in the long term such as protections against mutations may be prime candidates for this (just as your intestines shut down during exhaustive exercise such as when running a marathon, not because you can do without them, but because they aren't priority one _now_)
- astazangasta 11y agoThe problem with any scenario involving somatic mutation is it cannot improve fitness, by definition. All this could mean is stress gives you cancer.
- JohnBooty 11y agoIf stress speeds up evolution, I'm pretty sure my kids will be seven feet tall with superpowers and genius-level intelligence.
- formula1 11y agoI think your misinterpreting evolution for impressive. Impressive comes from females selecting their mates snd having the time to focus on something. Evolution from stress will create people that know how to reach a goal and adapt to environment. Funny short people are an example of adaptation, being tall is seen as preferable but being funny is an action you can take attract groups and mates. Our current environment rewards good networking, figuring out ways to pass arbitrary tests and taking advantage of opportunities. Generally the second is done through memorization though delegating is not uncommon. Money/financial system isnt the only way of taking advantage of a system. The genes passed on are usually those of who breed most, polygamists or people who put joy before responsibility. Your kids will likely use their strongest muscles (what you used the most) to try and survive in the pressence of what will be the next environment (more homework and pop music). Unless your a laborer or a cop, they likely wont be that strong. Unless you actually solved hard problems, they likely wont be that genius. But under the stress, theyll figure out a way or fail trying
- astazangasta 11y ago>The genes passed on are usually those of who breed most, polygamists or people who put joy before responsibility. One of the nice things about being a sexually reproducing species with a diploid genome, recombination, etc, is we get independent assortment of alleles. Evolution thus happens at the level of the genetic variant, not the individual. You can't fuck harder to ensure the fitness of your genes. This is why eugenics doesn't work.
- wyager 11y agoCould you expand on that? I'm not sure how your earlier statements imply that eugenics doesn't work.
- 11y ago
- dschiptsov 11y agoIt probably deminishes reproductive success, increases accident and mortality rates, etc. People are getting clumsy, narrow-minded and repetitive under continuous stress, so the "better adapted", who in the long run will reproduce more, would not necessarily be the best specimens.
- jimothyhalpert7 11y agoCould anyone explain how this, if at all, relates to the Yerkes–Dodson inverted-U[1]? [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yerkes%E2%80%93Dodson_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yerkes%E2%80%93Dodson_law
- Retra 11y agoHow does evolution 'speed up?' I can understand increasing variance or moving the mean or what-have-you, but the only way 'speeding up' evolution makes sense to me is if you start having children earlier.
- Ericson2314 11y agoIs it just me, or does Nautillus especially love stories that "disrupt the dogma"? That might help explain why their articles are especially popular around here. [This isn't really a criticism though, unexpected results are much more fascinating to read about.]