5 ms·
What I don't fully understand: are they going to replace google ads with their own ads? Is it even legal? There are battles whether blocking ads is legal, but r
by vbezhenar 11y ago
What I don't fully understand: are they going to replace google ads with their own ads? Is it even legal? There are battles whether blocking ads is legal, but replacing someone's ads with your own ads looks like potential trouble. Imagine if Google Chrome will adopt that approach.
And if they won't replace other ads but only interact with their partners, I don't see how that'll work. There are billions of websites, unless they got some really big contracts, they won't make it.
Interesting project, anyway.
- spacehome 11y agoWell, why not? If taking ads out is legal, then why not putting ads in? What country are you talking about? (Legality of course depends on country.) What law could they be breaking? And bonus points if there's somebody else who's ever been prosecuted for something remotely similar.
- bhickey 11y agoCleanFlicks was a Utah company that bowdlerized films. The Directors Guild successfully sued them for copyright infringement.
- sp332 11y agoSince there's no copying or redistribution going on, copyright doesn't seem relevant.
- bhickey 11y agoI wouldn't be so sure of this. ClearPlay, for example, works by marking video frames where unwanted content appears and then skipping over them during playback. The Family Home Movie Act 2005 carved out an exception for this in 17 USC 10(11): https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/110 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/110 There's an analogy between deleting objectionable portions of a film and parts of a website. I'll ask my copyright attorney friends, I'd bet this is an unresolved question.
- sp332 11y agoOk. And remember that the copyright holder for the page doesn't own the copyright in the ads you're blocking, so each copyrighted work might be loaded in its entirety or not at all. Other transformations have been done on webpages forever. In fact blocking all images was a built-in feature of most browsers until a few years ago.