4 ms·
This could be ameliorated via changes to the tax system. For instance, a higher tax rate for non-owner-occupied property, or a higher marginal tax rate for ever
by jacobolus 11y ago
This could be ameliorated via changes to the tax system. For instance, a higher tax rate for non-owner-occupied property, or a higher marginal tax rate for everything beyond the first 1000 square feet.
The problem in most cities though is insufficient housing to meet local demand, rather than foreign investment per se. So maybe Georgist land value taxes combined with relaxed zoning requirements (e.g. less parking requirement, smaller minimum unit sizes, taller height limits, more mixed residential/commercial zones, etc.) would be a better approach.
In San Francisco, for example, something like 3/4 of the city is zoned to only allow 1–2 units per lot, and is made up of single-family detached homes, with excessively wide streets and tons of parking. If even a fraction of this land was re-zoned to allow 5-story mixed use buildings, downtown Paris style, the city could fit a lot more housing.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI was going to say something similar. There is plenty of opportunity to apply taxes here on "tertiary" housing, houses which are not the primary residence of the owner. Sufficiently targeted requirements would hit the .1% and leave the rest unscathed. Of course those folks have a tremendous ability to encourage a different policy, but more and more cities could use the additional funding.
- mattzito 11y agoAs a Manhattan resident, the problem you describe isn't really the one being addressed by de blasio's plan. "Billionaires row" in midtown was already expensive real estate beforehand in a very desirable neighborhood, it just got converted into giant wealth safety deposit boxes. The Williamsburg example from the article is more of the core problem being addressed - how do we allow a neighborhood that was not so desirable to be redeveloped without blowing it to bits. I do also believe we should tax non-primary residence apartments for the reasons you describe, but it's a separate problem.
- sokoloff 11y ago[Differentially] Taxing non-resident housing encourages buying first houses on the margin, but also hurts renters (as the tax is passed through in the rental economics). I'm not saying it's all bad, but it's sure not all good either...
- eru 11y agoThat's why you tax land, not houses. Land value taxes can't be passed through.