17 ms·
Red Hat, Jetbrains and Unity Join Dotnet Foundation
- oneweekwonder 11y agoI'm uninformed on this topic, but with all the movement in the .net community. How will it play out for Oracle and Java? This is pure speculation I know, but would be interesting to read some opinions from people that is more informed. Any links or comments would be appreciated.
- meddlepal 11y agoJVM developer here, I think it has legs, but it's a couple years away from truly being a threat to Oracle and Java. The VM, tools and libraries are a lot less advanced and or non-existent in comparison to JVM-langs. If developers hop on board and start building the ecosystem then I think Oracle should be concerned. That could take anywhere from 2 to 10 years IMO.
- Deusdies 11y agoI would say the biggest threat to Java is Oracle themselves.
- jjawssd 11y agoDing Ding Ding "Perhaps the final straw was what Gosling said was Oracle's move to rein him in. indeed they owned Sun and thus Java, so they also owned its creator and his intellectual property, so it was up to Oracle to decide what Gosling or anybody else had to say about Java." http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Application-Development/Java-Creator-James-Gosling-Why-I-Quit-Oracle-813517 http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Application-Development/Java-Creato...
- meddlepal 11y agoBut this doesn't really make any sense... Sun was a historically bad steward of Java after 1.5. Oracle has done a lot to advance the language and ecosystem since acquisition.
- pjmlp 11y agoI have a foot in both communities. Around 10 years ago, developing Java enterprise desktop applications was a mix of pure Swing, SWT, Eclipse RCP and Netbeans Platform. Nowadays, just speaking from our customer projects, it is .NET for Windows only applications and Web for everything else. The only place where Java based UIs still matters are on Android. And on mobile OS, thanks to Oracle not caring about iOS and Windows Phone, C++ and C# are the languages to go for portable native apps. With Xamarin being made available for free, this will increase C# (including F#) usage for such applications. Currently .NET Core lacks a story for portable UI framework, but if it gets one, it might win some adoption outside Windows for desktop apps, at least more than Java, as JavaFX doesn't seem to be wining much mind-share. Another advantage of .NET Core is that Microsoft is having AOT compilation for free, while on Java world the best AOT compilers are commercial. However for server side UNIX applications, mainframes and embedded devices, there Java might still rule, specially thanks to the existing developer base. Also pure speculation from my part.
- javajosh 11y agoWell all this has been true for 10 years. There is still a little life in Java desktop GUIs because all the Java IDEs are written in Java (Netbeans and IntelliJ on Swing and Eclipse on SWT), but no one wants line-of-business software that is thick client, and they haven't since they realized they could reduce administration costs, and lose little functionality. (The exception in my experience being JPL which does some SWT work). The two interesting things that actually compete with Java (JVM) would be LLVM and WebAssembly (or asm.js if you prefer). On another front there is the thing that is competing with a big chunk of the SmallTalk OOP GUIs, a little thing called React. And actually Redux (or something like it) may turn out to be even more influential. My take is that the functional dynamic DOM environment of the browser complete with run-time remote linking and compiling is like the harsh environment of Arrakis, which was the only thing that could have given rise to such hardy technology. P.S. I really have to wonder how much a combination of `System.out.println` and `public static void main(String[] args)` cost the Java ecosystem. Not to mention the Date and File 'idioms'. Having nice collections and solid vm spec and implementation doesn't mean you get to ignore API usability. Sigh.
- _pmf_ 11y agoJetbrains will be acquired by either Microsoft or Google; I think it's a matter of weeks rather than months.
- meddlepal 11y agoGoogle makes a logical partner for JB. IntelliJ is already the foundation of Android Studio and Kotlin could be a replacement for Java on Android.
- taylorbuley 11y agoFacebook uses its toolset. That's who I'm hoping for! But secretly, JB's stewardship of the developer perspective is worthy of independence.
- andor 11y agoWhy do you think so? Microsoft has good developer tools of their own, Google is already building Android Studio on the IntelliJ platform without owning the company. Making IDE's is neither company's core business. I'm sure Jetbrains is a healthy business, but for Google or MS it's peanuts. I don't see the benefit of them owning Jetbrains, whereas on the contrary it would be good for Jetbrains to stay neutral.
- quicklyfrozen 11y agoResharper and Jetbrain's other .net tools may be enough of a reason, would be a nice add to VS. Also, MS is clearly showing an interest in Linux ATM and I doubt VS is going cross platform anytime soon, and they know the value of good developer tools.
- tonyedgecombe 11y agoI hope not, I don't want to see developer tools come down to a choice of Apple, Microsoft or Google.
- alimbada 11y agoThis is wild speculation at best. If anything, Jetbrains seem to be extremely resistant to being absorbed by larger entities.
- supercheetah 11y agoHonest question, how many .NET developers actually write stuff for Linux on the server side? How many have a significant user base? I know there are a few desktop Linux apps (e.g. Tomboy, and Banshee), but I haven't seen many used in a daemon or as an Apache mod or the like.
- sciurus 11y agoNot many... yet.
- noir_lord 11y agoNo but I (and I suspect lots of former .net devs) am watching closely. I'd really like to have true first class C# support on Linux. Never really gotten on with Java so a lot of our backend stuff is in Python and PHP.
- traskjd 11y agoWe (https://raygun.com https://raygun.com) use a lot of .NET on the server side. We also use golang, node and a few other things, but a lot of .NET, specifically with C#. We're very excited about being able to run on Linux. There's plenty of our back end worker processes that are in C# and being able to move them to Linux will be a big win for us (manageability, cost, etc). I'm not sure what you consider a significant user base, but we do have 40k+ devs on our platform, and we process billions of interactions and software exceptions every month from many of the top 100 web sites and apps globally.
- TheLogothete 11y agoI would have loved it better if MS chose Cent over Ubuntu.
- jjawssd 11y agoMost of the new university graduates from top schools are used to using Ubuntu.
- dsp1234 11y agoDoes CentOS provide any type of enterprise support options?
- nwatson 11y agoIt's called RHEL.
- psibi 11y agoThe post doesn't refer to Ubuntu's unity but the game engine Unity.
- TheLogothete 11y agoYou don't say!