4 ms·
People want charismatic leaders, but I don't think we need them. In fact, I think they are extremely dangerous. Think for a moment about JFK's catch phrase: "A
by yummyfajitas 19y ago
People want charismatic leaders, but I don't think we need them. In fact, I think they are extremely dangerous. Think for a moment about JFK's catch phrase:
"Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country."
Compare it to catch phrases of other charismatic leaders:
"All within the State, Nothing outside the State, Nothing against the State"
"The common good comes before the private good."
(Sorry for invoking Godwin, but it's important to point out how his charisma obscured what JFK actually said.)
I think it's far better to have a leader that everyone hates. Just think of the outcry if Bush suggested the people should serve the state.
- pchristensen 19y ago"I think it's far better to have a leader that everyone hates." Unless that leader has given even the uninformed a reason to hate him ...
- yummyfajitas 19y agoA charismatic leader can give the uninformed a reason to hate him, but it won't change their feelings. An example: a gay friend of mine dislikes Bush because he proposed a law against gay marriage (at least that is his stated reason). He has very strong positive feelings for (Bill) Clinton, in spite of the fact that Clinton actually passed a law against gay marriage (Defense of Marriage Act). His feelings persisted even after I pointed this out to him. Maybe I just have stupid friends (I don't think this is the case), but my general impression is that most people don't base their opinion of a politician on policy. Rather, they take their opinion on the policy from the party or politician they like.
- edw519 19y agoWhat about RFK's catch phrase, "Others ask why; I ask why not."
- yummyfajitas 19y agoI thought T-rex invented generative catch phrases/advice. http://www.qwantz.com/archive/001159.html http://www.qwantz.com/archive/001159.html