2 ms·
> In a system without any real rules or authority, I think "those adversely effected choosing to block the bad actor" is a fairly democratic solution to the pro
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> In a system without any real rules or authority, I think "those adversely effected choosing to block the bad actor" is a fairly democratic solution to the problem.
That's the part which is adverse to the rest of your argument. You're not voting off the bad actor, you're voting off everyone in the bad actor's country.
We know how to deal with this problem. You go to a website, you sign up for an account, it can be pseudonymous but to get it you have to put up some collateral. Money/Bitcoin, proof of work, vouching by an existing member, whatever you like. Then if your account misbehaves you forfeit your collateral.
But this isn't a CloudFlare-level problem. They're trying to solve it at the wrong layer of abstraction. Identity isn't a global invariant, it's a relationship between individuals. Endpoints identify each other with persistent pseudonyms. The middle of the network should have nothing to do with it.
- nucleardog 11y ago> That's the part which is adverse to the rest of your argument. You're not voting off the bad actor, you're voting off everyone in the bad actor's country. The bad actor is the organization or person responsible for administering the network where the abuse is originating. When I'm being attacked by someone's VPS, I report them to their host. After the fourth time I report them only to have their host pass along my report but take no further action, the host becomes, maybe not a bad actor but, a "bad citizen". My choices are to allow them to externalize the costs of their lack of enforcement (or decision not to enforce) and attempt to find a way to block the specific actor under their purview, or just to block that host and accept whatever collateral damage that occurs. (And yes, sometimes that "bad citizen" may end up being most of a country - it doesn't change the equation for me.) It's the only method I have to exert any pressure on the host to act responsibly. If enough people agree with me, then it quickly becomes "their problem" rather than "my problem" as they get blackholed from everywhere on the internet.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> The bad actor is the organization or person responsible for administering the network where the abuse is originating. The bad actor is the individual who acts bad. The Post Office is not a bad actor for delivering letters. > allow them to externalize the costs of their lack of enforcement Tor is not an enforcement agency. Neither is CloudFlare. The costs of bad actors are your costs. You have the technical ability to retaliate against common carriers for not allowing you to push those costs onto them, but that doesn't make you right to do it in any sense other than might makes right. And you should realize that in doing it you're knowingly hurting innocent people.
- pink_dinner 11y ago"The bad actor is the individual who acts bad. The Post Office is not a bad actor for delivering letters." If they actively ignored death threats/didn't send them off to the police when it came to their attention, they become responsible. "The costs of bad actors are your costs." Cloudflare is sick and tired of getting attacked by people from the TOR network. I don't blame them for the ban. It's costing them money..and TOR isn't going to raise the funds to pay them for the lost bandwidth and customer revenue. We used to have a bigger problem with mail spam because server operators constantly would leave anonymous relaying open. How did we stop a great deal of it? By blacklisting the IP until the problem is fixed. It has worked out pretty well. "And you should realize that in doing it you're knowingly hurting innocent people." I guess we have to determine which 'innocent' people are more important: The ones getting their websites attacked and hacked anonymously, the people that can't access those websites because they are down/DOS attacked, or the random people that want to use the TOR network.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> If they actively ignored death threats/didn't send them off to the police when it came to their attention, they become responsible. The Post Office reads your mail? > We used to have a bigger problem with mail spam because server operators constantly would leave anonymous relaying open. How did we stop a great deal of it? By blacklisting the IP until the problem is fixed. It has worked out pretty well. Only if you're willing to disregard innocent people. > I guess we have to determine which 'innocent' people are more important: The ones getting their websites attacked and hacked anonymously, the people that can't access those websites because they are down/DOS attacked, or the random people that want to use the TOR network. The "random people" who use Tor aren't doing it because it's trendy. They're doing it because it's the only way they can access the internet. Or because not using it would get them stoned to death by religious fundamentalists or imprisoned by an oppressive government.
- nucleardog 11y agoOf course they're not an enforcement agency, that's kind of the point - there is no enforcement agency. We all have to contribute by being good citizens. I subscribe to the idea that it's an ISP's responsibility to police its own network for abuse and my responsibility to police mine. You apparently subscribe to the idea that it's my responsibility to just accept whatever shit you fling at me and it's my problem to deal with and yet somehow I have a responsibility or moral obligation to still provide services to you and your customers. I suspect I'm never going to agree with you.