4 ms·
>The system works fine for day to day politics, but it breaks down horribly when decisive action needs to be taken. That's the point of it, though. The system
by cookiecaper 17y ago
>The system works fine for day to day politics, but it breaks down horribly when decisive action needs to be taken.
That's the point of it, though. The system was intentionally designed to make it difficult to get a law passed, on the theory that any bill that can survive the process to become a law and then withstand reviews from the judiciary regarding its constitutionality must be pretty good and important, or it wouldn't get passed.
The Constitution and the form of government it establishes is there to abrogate the powers of the ruling class. The whole point is to make it difficult for the government to do things.
There are some exceptions; for instance, the President is Commander-in-Chief and generally is granted at least some leeway in the unauthorized usage of force if there is an imminent danger to American citizens, though technically only the Congress can authorize a full-on war. Some other emergency powers are reckoned to the President or his municipal equivalents in the case of martial law, etc.
Our government makes some allotment for extraordinary powers when the exclusion of them would cause significant destruction, but in general the idea is for things to go slow.
This isn't really compatible with the way our government is used today, which is sad condemnation of our generations, imo.
- cookiecaper 17y agoLet me say here, though, that the above regards the federal government. The United States of America is a group of independent states on the American continent, just as the European Union is a group of independent states on the European continent. As such, these things are imposed upon the federal government in part because the majority of laws are intended to be enacted by local governments, like states and cities. Each state in the United States has its own constitution and is free to make its own legislative procedures insofar as such procedures do not contradict the Bill of Rights contained in the federal Constitution. For instance, if Kansas wanted to do away with free speech, they would have to withdraw from the union to do so (theoretically), as such a prohibition is contrary to the constitution of the union of independent American states. Or by contrast, if the federal government wanted to impose a law which said all people must wear a seat belt while riding in a car, this would be violate of the federal Constitution and the independent states are free to reject such a law (theoretically). The federal Constitution is clear that any powers not explicitly delegated to the federal government are within the purview of the state. Now, that's the idea. In reality, states make laws and operate under procedures that circumvent fundamental rights frequently, and the federal government enforces its will by withholding funding or imposing other forms of ostracization upon any state that doesn't comply (see age 21 drinking age). Things are even worse now, and constitutions are rarely upheld -- the congresses and legislatures at both federal and state levels just pass whatever they like with complete disregard for its legality, and the public lets them do it -- as long as the public can get their American Idol and Zoloft there are no problems there. The whole thing is just really sad.
- cschneid 17y agoYou started off so strong. You really did. Next time avoid the "hurf durf, people are so dumb" line at the end. I made a very similar point on another comment in this thread, that basically the states should be making the majority of the laws, but they've let themselves get tied up with very restrictive rules (at least in the few states I'm familiar with). As far as truly unconstitutional laws, I don't think they happen nearly as much as you think they do.