7 ms·
"Last Train from Hiroshima" author says he was duped
- patio11 17y ago“This book is a Toyota,” said Robert S. Norris, the author of “Racing for the Bomb” and an atomic historian. “The publisher should recall it, issue an apology and fix the parts that endanger the historical record.” Some people in my neighborhood are going to get dragged over the coals tomorrow morning (again) for the first five words of this quote.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoI was going to comment on that line, too. However! This kind of coinage dates quickly. In 2000-2001, people started using "Nasdaqed" as a verb for "dropped precipitously." (http://archives.econ.utah.edu/archives/a-list/2002/msg00256.htm http://archives.econ.utah.edu/archives/a-list/2002/msg00256....). It died after a while, even though the Nasdaq is still below where it was when people started using the term.
- nonrecursive 17y agoThere's something macabre about using the name of one of the most celebrated Japanese companies to disparage a book because it inaccurately asserts that Little Boy could have killed a lot more Japanese.
- mronge 17y agoThat is a pretty significant error. It puts the whole book's accuracy into question because clearly the author didn't do his research thoroughly.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoThank God he’s not alive. He was so proud. I often hear that, regardless of whether or not I agree with any particular war, the world needs more men willing to "stand up for freedom". I think the world needs less men who are willing to kill just because someone else told them it was for freedom.
- hga 17y agoHow are you so sure he was unaware of, for example, how murderously brutal the Greater East Asian Co-prosperity Sphere was? Right up to the surrender Imperial Japan was killing six figures worth of people every month. There are rather a lot of Chinese and Koreans who are alive today because we ended that regime as quickly and decisively as we could. Granted, we did that mostly to save the lives of our own people and so we wouldn't have to do it again, but that doesn't diminish the overall set of benefits.
- cma 17y ago>There are rather a lot of Chinese and Koreans who are alive today because we ended that regime as quickly and decisively as we could. Didn't we keep supplying oil (something like 70-80%) and steel to Japan throughout the first half of their China campaign?
- hga 17y agoYes, and we stopped specifically because of their China campaign, which then precipitated the greater war. What point are you trying to make?
- cma 17y agoThat it took 3 or 4 years to do so. That the "thankful" Chinese might have several caveats. Especially since "and we stopped specifically because of their China campaign" isn't exactly true, since in actuality we waited until they attacked a French colony before we put up the embargo.
- hga 17y agoWho's this "we" you're referring to? "We" aren't a dictatorship, "we" don't turn on a dime and immediately decide to destroy another country. "We" tend to try diplomacy first, "we" had to learn that lessor measures wouldn't work (e.g. the Flying Tigers) and that Japan's behavior towards adversaries had changed since WWI or perhaps was different than it had been with Western ones (e.g. Russia), "we" also included the U.K. and Netherlands (other majors sources of steel and oil). You're trying to create a moral equivalency that I can't quite figure out this early in the morning but that doesn't make any sense to me, so for now I'll just point out that you want perfection, you're not going to find it in international diplomacy and war. ADDED: Ah, are you trying to say that because our behavior prior to the war was imperfect, we didn't then have the moral standing to end it in a way that ensured we would be able to make sure it didn't continue in due course, as with WWI -> WII? FURTHER ADDED: Also remember that at the time we the US were responsible for the defense and general well being of the Philippines and that the costs of any war our action provoked with the regional power would inevitably fall more heavily on its inhabitants. Our reaction to Imperial Japan's aggression was necessarily not a simple thing.
- teeja 17y agoTypical. 70,000 killed and people get upset about who was on the plane. Ah, Bartleby.
- eli 17y agoWow, that's some surprisingly shoddy fact checking. And how do you miss running this past a group of veterans from the unit that dropped the bombs when they're even putting out a regular newsletter?