5 ms·
U.S. government poisoned alcohol during Prohibition, with deadly consequences
- maurycy 17y agoWere they lawbreakers if there was no trial? I'd say that you're innocent unless proven guilty.
- tedunangst 17y agoDid you read the article? If they were innocent, how did the alcohol with the poison get inside them?
- jrockway 17y agoThat's for the jury to decide. If the punishment for drinking alcohol is death, then it's very likely that the jury will nullify. Poisoning the alcohol removes this possibility. (There is a reason you have a right to a jury trial, after all.)
- tedunangst 17y agoWhat's for the jury to decide? The alcohol wasn't poisoned to punish people. The goverment said "this alcohol is poisoned, don't drink it." People drank it anyway. Where does the jury enter the picture?
- jrockway 17y agoNot everyone drinking the alcohol knew it was poisoned. If they knew it was poisoned, they probably wouldn't have consumed it! "Depraved indifference to human life" is murder. Putting poison in something you know someone will probably drink, even if you tell them not to, is depraved indifference to human life. Murder. You should go out of your way to not kill people -- this is the opposite. Like I said, if the death penalty is the punishment for drinking alcohol, fine. But the death penalty doesn't mean you can just murder people. There is a procedure to follow -- a trial, evidence proving the case beyond a reasonable doubt, appeals, etc. You can't just kill someone that committed a crime; you have to prove it first. The government needs to be held to a higher standard than the average man, and if the average man did this, he would be in prison for murder. What the government did, in this case, is inexcusable state-sponsored mass murder. (Thought experiment: you have a party, and have a punch bowl sitting out. Next to it is a small sign that says: "Poison: do not drink." A few guests drink it anyway, and by the end of the night you have a stack of five dead bodies. Do you really think that you won't be convicted of five counts of murder? A disclaimer doesn't mean you can try to kill people!)
- byrneseyeview 17y agoThat's the difference between the legal concept and the regular one. You're a lawbreaker when you break the law; you're guilty when a court procedure agrees.
- maurycy 17y agoI'd say that there's no difference between the legal concept and the regular one. I don't know how in the US, but in Europe it is illegal to write publicly "Joe Average, a murderer", if the person had no trial, yet. Regardless of the widely available proofs. After the fact - once the jury decided you are innocent - it is extremely hard to get your good name back.
- ErrantX 17y ago> I don't know how in the US, but in Europe it is illegal to write publicly "Joe Average, a murderer", if the person had no trial, yet. Regardless of the widely available proofs. Nope. The beauty of free speech is that it's only illegal if it's either untrue or you cant prove it (which are in essence the same thing in the eyes of the law) :)
- byrneseyeview 17y ago(1926)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 17y agoOriginal title is more informative and less sensational: The little-told story of how the U.S. government poisoned alcohol during Prohibition with deadly consequences.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoFrom the HN submit page: Please make title < 80 characters.
- tedunangst 17y ago"U.S. government poisoned alcohol during Prohibition"
- pvg 17y ago"U.S. government poisoned alcohol during Prohibition with deadly consequences" (76 chars) Is still much better than making stuff up. The government did not 'poison lawbreakers without trial'. It makes it sound like they took someone in custody and fed them poison.
- fexl 17y agoCorrect, it was murder from afar.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYou are right, your proposed title would have been better. But I disagree that my title was "making stuff up". The government did indeed poison lawbreakers without a trial, it just did not do so in the specific manner you describe.
- amalcon 17y agoThe problem with saying that they "poisoned people without a trial" is much the same as the problem with saying that a police officer who shot a suspect brandishing a gun "shot the suspect without a trial." It's technically true, but it puts a totally unnecessary spin on the events, as a trial is neither expected nor required.
- JshWright 17y ago"As one of its most outspoken opponents, Charles Norris, the chief medical examiner of New York City..." Is there anything Chuck Norris _can't_ do?
- akamaka 17y agoThis is pretty terrible journalism. It discusses deaths from people drinking denatured alcohol when it was first introduced in 1920s prohibition USA, but doesn't provide any context. Denatured alcohol is still widely sold today, without any controvresy. It has poisonous additives, but is cheaper because it's not taxed. There's a genuine public health issue here, which the article also ignores. Drinking is a massive problem in some parts of the world where alcohol is poorly controlled. Half of all premature deaths of working age Russian men are due to alcohol consumption. And while many of those come from drinking poisonous alcohols, the majority are from plain old vodka.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- goodside 17y agoIn most US states, methylated alcohols, along with most household cleaners and automotive fluids, are required to contain substances like bitrex to make them so extremely unpalatable that the risk of consumption is negligible. In some countries in Europe, denatured alcohol is required by law to not contain any methanol (thus raising its price) and is denatured only by bitrex, which has no health risks beyond its flavor.
- wooster 17y ago"Half of all premature deaths of working age Russian men are due to alcohol consumption." Color me skeptical on that. The average life expectancy of Russian males in 2008 was 61.83, whereas the retirement age in Russia is 60. I can't find statistics on working age males specifically, but the general breakdown of causes of death among Russians as a population suggests that cardiovascular disease and cancer (which could include conditions caused by alcohol consumption) would swamp deaths caused by alcohol consumption itself: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Russia#Health http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Russia#Health I'd be genuinely curious to see any stats you have contradicting that analysis, however.
- jasonkester 17y agoHave you ever been to Russia? Walk the streets of Moscow at 7am, and you'll see businessmen on their way to work, halfway through their first bottle of vodka. It's hard to believe if you don't see it, but a significant fraction of the people there are drunk or drinking all the time. So no, even though I haven't seen any hard numbers, I don't have any problem believing the grandparent's claim.
- yannis 17y agoAdditives are still added to make alcohol poisonous and unpalatable, in addition in many countries a coloring is added. Traditionally, the main additive is 10% methanol, giving rise to the term methylated spirit. See also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denatured_alcohol http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denatured_alcohol The article was sensational in 1926 and probably still is.
- Confusion 17y agoUsually it's the other way around: unpalatable additives are added to already poisonous substances, to prevent them from being consumed. The usual example is cleaning alcohol: it already contains methanol (because it is cheaper than ethanol and because it has different properties, which makes for better cleaning alcohol) and the coloring, smelling and vomit-reflex-inducing substances are added to prevent poor, ignorant slobs from going blind and paralysed (and eventually dead) by drinking it.
- yannis 17y agoNot really! see (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denatured_alcohol http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Denatured_alcohol). Since normal alcohol (ethanol) is highly taxed (sin tax), additives are added to stop people from using it other than for industrial or medical use or even to make it difficult to distill again, hence they add methanol and the additives. The tax man has protected himself very carefully :)
- goodside 17y agoYes, really. Pure ethanol is more expensive than methylated alcohol (which has both ethanol and methanol) even before taxes are applied. Denaturing existing pure ethanol with methanol is wasteful, as the constituants are more valuable separated. In Poland, alcohol is by law denatured only with safe, taste-altering substances, and so their denatured alcohol is more expensive than in other countries because industrial manufacturers have to produce the stuff methanol-free.
- 17y ago
- idlewords 17y agoSomething similar is in place now with medications containing codeine derivatives (such as Percocet). In the US, they invariably contain a high dose of acetaminophen, specifically included to deter abuse. This guarantees that anyone trying to take a large recreational dose of painkillers is risking liver failure. It looks like the FDA may have finally decided this is a terrible idea: http://www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/06/30/acetaminophen.fda.hearing/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2009/HEALTH/06/30/acetaminophen.fda.heari...
- mike_organon 17y agoThat linked article does not say acetaminophen is an intentional poison, but that its is an active drug that now appears to have side effects, and they also want to remove it from medicines where it is the primary ingredient.
- idlewords 17y ago"Analgesic nephropathy is the direct result of the DEA's deliberate policy of using APAP as a denaturation agent for narcotics, in the same way methanol was used to denature ethanol that wasn't meant to be drunk" http://yarchive.net/med/anti_inflammatories.html http://yarchive.net/med/anti_inflammatories.html
- cynicalkane 17y agoIANAD (am not a doctor), but codeine is allegedly more effective at smaller doses when paired with other painkillers. Smaller doses = less potential to develop an abusive dependency. It's fun to see sinister intentions in government policies, and maybe they are sinister, I don't know. But there's nothing sinister about arranging things so that significantly less dangerous are more widely available to the public than are doses of straight codeine. That some druggies destroy their livers with Vikes/Percocet is tragic, but it's strange that the usually libertarian-leaning Hacker News would be so opposed to making good painkillers available by prescription. There is something nanny-state-ish about removing a relatively safe painkiller from the market because of what abusers might do with it. Also, the doctor you quoted seems rather paranoid...
- barnaby 17y agoNow that I'm reading "People's history of the United States" by Howard Zinn, I'm not surprised by anything anymore. I guess all governments do this kind of stuff (and worse) on a routine basis.
- gills 17y agoI guess all [illegitimate] governments [murder their own citizens] (and worse) on a routine basis. There. Fixed it for ya.
- ams6110 17y agoI'm not familiar with that work, but I was also going to say this is an illustration of how you can never really trust governments to always do the right thing.
- tungstenfurnace 17y agoThe war on vice is properly regarded as a private war fought within each individual.
- vegas 17y agoHere's the obit for the chuck norris that was: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1965874/pdf/bullnyacadmed00874-0061.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1965874/pdf/bull...