4 ms·

Firstly I am very sorry for your experience growing up in China, but do note that many others grew up normally in China and continued on with their lives. I ag

Firstly I am very sorry for your experience growing up in China, but do note that many others grew up normally in China and continued on with their lives. I agree with all the problems that you listed, but I believe the spreading of rumors is a problem that has to be tackled. It is true that there are many more problems to attend to, but why not fix them one by one, starting from the most obvious ones like rumors.

nathanm412 11y ago
Wouldn't a culture of rumors arising from a distrust of government press be better tackled by establishing freedom of the press rather than adding more restrictions?
- deleted 11y ago
  [deleted]
- paradite 11y ago
  I do believe freedom of press is the way moving forward. However at the same time, restricting rumours (actual rumours that have no grounds or basis) for the time being would help for people who have less discretion to be better informed.
  - tamana 11y ago
    So only the government should be allowed to spread false information?
    - paradite 11y ago
      Can you substantiate your claim?
      - calbear81 11y ago
        The use of propaganda is well established within the PRC (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_the_People's_Republic_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_the_People's_Rep...). I'm more interested in the idea that "rumors" are a problem that needs to be tackled and the best way to do so is to ban them and only trust what is coming from the government. Isn't this type of system ripe for abuse? Let's say a rumor was that a certain government official embezzled $100M Yuan, but it was true. Perhaps that would be very embarrassing for the central party and thus they issue a statement saying that is not the case. Isn't it the public that is hurt in this situation?
        paradite 11y ago
        Hi. Your example, by definition, does not involve rumours. Hence if the government tries to hide it, it is the government's fault and we should blame the government. However, you might not realize that there are many other rumours in China that are not true, and has nothing to do with the government per se, such as a disease outbreak or a certain foreign firm exploiting fellow Chinese people. These are the rumours that we need to fight. I do not expect you to believe me though. After all you would not know any of those without living in China for a few years.
deleted 11y ago
[deleted]

nathanm412 11y ago

Wouldn't a culture of rumors arising from a distrust of government press be better tackled by establishing freedom of the press rather than adding more restrictions?

deleted 11y ago
[deleted]
paradite 11y ago
I do believe freedom of press is the way moving forward. However at the same time, restricting rumours (actual rumours that have no grounds or basis) for the time being would help for people who have less discretion to be better informed.
- tamana 11y ago
  So only the government should be allowed to spread false information?
  - paradite 11y ago
    Can you substantiate your claim?
    - calbear81 11y ago
      The use of propaganda is well established within the PRC (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_the_People's_Republic_of_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda_in_the_People's_Rep...). I'm more interested in the idea that "rumors" are a problem that needs to be tackled and the best way to do so is to ban them and only trust what is coming from the government. Isn't this type of system ripe for abuse? Let's say a rumor was that a certain government official embezzled $100M Yuan, but it was true. Perhaps that would be very embarrassing for the central party and thus they issue a statement saying that is not the case. Isn't it the public that is hurt in this situation?
      - paradite 11y ago
        Hi. Your example, by definition, does not involve rumours. Hence if the government tries to hide it, it is the government's fault and we should blame the government. However, you might not realize that there are many other rumours in China that are not true, and has nothing to do with the government per se, such as a disease outbreak or a certain foreign firm exploiting fellow Chinese people. These are the rumours that we need to fight. I do not expect you to believe me though. After all you would not know any of those without living in China for a few years.

deleted 11y ago

[deleted]