4 ms·
The main point of Tor is that nobody knows where the traffic comes from. Realize you're asking them to break their own service. Your premise seems to be that y
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
The main point of Tor is that nobody knows where the traffic comes from. Realize you're asking them to break their own service.
Your premise seems to be that you can't be bothered to protect your networks so you want to put that responsibility on someone else. It's called intermediary liability and it's terrible because the intermediary has all the wrong incentives.
You demand that the intermediary eliminate malicious traffic but they suffer much less than individual users if they also eliminate non-malicious traffic, so they set up a system with a high rate of false positives and harm many honest people. YouTube does this with Content ID. Spam registries do this with innocent small mail servers. CloudFlare does this with Tor.
What you're doing is called externalizing costs. It's generally recognized as antisocial behavior. So if you're going to claim benefits to yourself at the expense of other people, at least recognize that you're doing it.
- jcoffland 11y agoGoogle does this with Linode servers. I route my HTTP traffic through a proxy on a Linode server. Google blocks me all the time for no reason other than that some other IPs in my range are doing bad things. I've tried to contact Google about this but they could care less about a handful of users.
- kuschku 11y agoComplain to a Google dev here on HN, I had the same issue with my OVH proxy.
- neoCrimeLabs 11y agoI've experienced the same issue from multiple service providers, including but not limited to Google, Akamai, Cloudflare, and more. My Linode IP address was assigned to me years ago. I do not use it maliciously, do not share it with other people, and have never used it for tor. Yet find myself regularly blocked for no logical reasons when I proxy my web-request through it.
- themartorana 11y ago"...you can't be bothered to protect your network..." Huh? Isn't this exactly what CF is attempting to do? And Tor traffic tends to be abusive so the good is caught up with the bad, but it's all in the name of protection.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> Isn't this exactly what CF is attempting to do? No. The real bad people have botnets and can cycle through a million random IP addresses every time you block one. A real solution needs to be secure against someone you don't yet know is bad. This is going to get a lot worse as we've run out of IPv4 addresses. ISPs are going to start to NAT many users behind one IP address. Some already have. Then you have the same issue as Tor where one user is malicious but shares the same IP address as a thousand innocent users. IP blocking isn't going to work anymore so you might as well find an alternative solution now.
- nucleardog 11y ago> What you're doing is called externalizing costs. It's generally recognized as antisocial behavior. So if you're going to claim benefits to yourself at the expense of other people, at least recognize that you're doing it. Remember his preface - cranky old-school network operator. Let's say you have a hundred networks all connected together into some sort of "inter-net" system. If one AS starts sending out malicious traffic, what makes more sense: 1. That AS starts policing their users. 2. The other 99 ASs have to deal with the malicious traffic. You're expecting the other 99 groups that are being targeted by the one group to bear the cost of dealing with that group's malicious users. Who exactly is externalizing costs here? In a system without any real rules or authority, I think "those adversely effected choosing to block the bad actor" is a fairly democratic solution to the problem. You either play nice or you get voted off of the island.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mdasher 11y agoWe're not dealing with 99 ASs blocking another bad actor. We're talking about one service that sits in front of many popular services on the internet deciding to block another for dubious reasons. Cloudflare has near monopoly power here.
- nucleardog 11y agoI guess I look at it differently - every site using CloudFare made the decision to delegate their web security to them. I don't see it as "one entity blocking another" but "all of those individual sites blocking a single network". In that context, it's a lot of votes for Tor to find a solution to this problem. Really, I'm surprised at CloudFare's restraint here. A lot of their customers probably couldn't care less about Tor, but they've been putting a lot of effort into trying to avoid blocking Tor users (actually blocking, not inconveniencing) or compromising their anonymity.
- zzzcpan 11y ago
- FussyZeus 11y agoThe problem with this kind of thinking is that yes, while content ID does catch a lot of false positives, and yes, it results in creators being dinged for no reason, the reason it was created in the first place was that too many people were abusing YouTube to distribute pirated material. It's the same cause/effect here with CloudFlare, too many people are abusing the anonymity Tor provides to do shitty things to their network. It's not as if CF set out to screw over Tor users, by the nature of Tor they'd have no way to do it with any kind of ease. Tor traffic just happens to have a whole lot of bad actors using it and that causes the reputation of those IP's to down.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoContent ID was created because Google wanted Hollywood content and Hollywood wanted to externalize costs. Copyright in the context of the internet has costs that can only be paid by innocent people. It will either have many false positives or many false negatives. So the question is whether those costs should be paid by the innocent people who benefit from the system that created those costs or the innocent people who don't.
- tracker1 11y agoTOR exit nodes could run an IDENT-like service, that offers only a hash based on the source of the traffic... it would still be psuedo-anonymous, but easier to filter by the target of said traffic.