4 ms·
What email client would you recommend? I've been stuck in Thunderbird because I require PGP/GPG, but I really hate it. Do you have a favorite client? I really d
by criddell 11y ago
What email client would you recommend? I've been stuck in Thunderbird because I require PGP/GPG, but I really hate it. Do you have a favorite client? I really do like Google's Inbox, but the lack of PGP is a blocker for me.
- gkya 11y agoGnus on Emacs was very good with IMAP for me, where sources were Fastmail and Gmail. Encryption and signing works, but I haven't used it in email that much, so I can't comment. Gnome's Evolution was good too, IIRC. There are also Mutt and Pine, but they are terminal clients, so IDK how they handle inline images, tho mutt was OK with html.
- ams6110 11y agoI use notmuch[1] in emacs, fetchmail to get email, and local MTA set up to deliver to my maildir. HTML email is rendered with w3m which does a decent job. Searching my local email with notmuch is blazing fast and works even better than Gmail's searching (IMO). Certainly not everyone's cup of tea but if you like emacs otherwise, it's a great alternative to Gnus. Gnus is originally and primarily a newsreader and treating email like news works in some ways but fails in others. Also searching in Gnus is something I never really got to work well. [1] https://notmuchmail.org/ https://notmuchmail.org/
- gkya 11y agoI'm using a rmail+m{pop,smtp}+mairix+spamassassin approach nowadays (My email provider's spam filtering is crap, so I do it myself, with a whitelist from my BBDB). Notmuch always seemed interesting but I couldn't dive in yet. I have some free time this week, so I'll try. If your configuration is public (i.e. on github), would you mind sharing a link?
- wishinghand 11y agoWhat don't you like about Thunderbird? I was about to recommend it as an email client to a client but hadn't heard any overt criticisms. Is it good at security but bad at UI?
- sliverstorm 11y agoIt's just clunky, not well organized, and slow. Like any open source project, the features are all there, but five minutes after installing it I was googling "Thunderbird slow redraw".
- criddell 11y agoI use Inbox and Gmail for my personal email, so that's what I'm comparing it to. I'm not a fan of Thunderbird's aesthetics, but obviously that's subjective. Functionally, a lot of my problems stem from the Enigmail plugin and Thunderbird search. It really wants encrypted mail to stay encrypted and that means search doesn't work. Last time I looked, there was some hacky workaround with configuring a filter to make a copy of incoming mail and decrypt the copy, but I couldn't get it to work reliably.
- Mahn 11y agoReally wish that we had a good, fast, Thunderbird alternative by now other than MS Outlook. But everyone seems to assume that you are supposed to use a web client like gmail now.
- nunez 11y agoI personally really liked using Mutt. I've stopped using it because snoozing emails is really, really useful, and no IMAP client supports this. (I hope that snoozing emails becomes part of the "next-gen" messaging protocol)
- bjacobel 11y agoAirmail for OSX has a PGP extension available.
- caminante 11y agoDo you actually "require" PGP, or is it just a preference? I ask because as Bruce Schneier pointed out, his email security's only as good as that of the people he messages. With so many people using gmail, outlook, yahoo, etc., striving for total privacy is expensive. Thus, I politely wonder whether you've set unrealistic expectations.
- criddell 11y agoIt's required by my employer. Almost all email I get is encrypted and/or signed. For services we have running that send email but don't know how to encrypt (like Redmine and Jenkins), I wrote a little smtp proxy that all it does is look at the from and to addresses, select appropriate keys, construct a new encrypted email and forward it to the real smtp server. It's written in Python and is super-simple but has worked for years now.
- dcposch 11y agoThat's really interesting. I care a lot about email encryption -- I want to make something better and easier to use than current PGP programs. One major hurdle is apathy. Talking to potential users, even if we could wave a magic wand and make end-to-end encryption effortless, many people just don't care. A few companies (and their associated governments) have vast central databases containing most of the world's mail. At one point that would've been considered dystopian, but today many people just take it for granted. I've previously worked in financial technology, and even financial advisors dealing with sensitive client info would always just use plain email. -- If you're comfortable telling me: what country and industry are you in? Is it the norm to require PGP use on the job, or is your employer an exception?
- robryk 11y agoIf the OP uses PGP only for signing and signature verification, it's not privacy he's after. If the OP uses PGP for encryption, then his conversation partners use it too, and thus can't use gmail, outlook or yahoo (I am under the impression that desktop outlook has no support for PGP).
- er0k 11y agohttp://supmua.org/ http://supmua.org/ https://github.com/sup-heliotrope/sup/wiki/gpg https://github.com/sup-heliotrope/sup/wiki/gpg
- Maarius 11y agohttps://www.postbox-inc.com/ https://www.postbox-inc.com/ is quite good. It is commercial software based on the source code of Thunderbird.
- criddell 11y agoI just took a look at PostBox and it looks great. Unfortunately, on their Add Ons page (https://www.postbox-inc.com/add-ons https://www.postbox-inc.com/add-ons) they only list Enigmail 1.2. Enigmail is up to version 1.9.x. IMHO, that's a pretty important add on to keep current.
- AndrewUnmuted 11y agoHere: https://dev.mutt.org/trac/wiki/MuttGuide/UseGPG https://dev.mutt.org/trac/wiki/MuttGuide/UseGPG is an article from Mutt's wiki demonstrating how to use PGP with Mutt. Mutt is pretty nice.
- AdieuToLogic 11y agoOld school choice: nmh[0]. It is a very different way of interacting with email. From section 1.2.1[1]: Because MH commands aren't part of a monolithic mail system, you can use them at any time; you don't have to start or quit the mail agent. It's fine to mix other UNIX commands between your MH commands, to leave your mail for a while and do something else, and to work at several terminals at the same time. Because you use MH commands from a shell prompt, you can use all the power of the shell. 0 - http://rand-mh.sourceforge.net/book/ http://rand-mh.sourceforge.net/book/ 1 - http://rand-mh.sourceforge.net/book/overall/howwor.html#EmaTrAge http://rand-mh.sourceforge.net/book/overall/howwor.html#EmaT...
- terinjokes 11y agoMH (and, by extension, nmh) is new to me, but I'm very interested. I hope you don't mind me asking a question. What tool are you using to synchronize with an MTA?
- AdieuToLogic 11y agoI've used Postfix+fetchmail successfully, but am going to look into "msmtp" mentioned by @gkya above as it is new to me. Also, OfflineIMAP[0] looks to be a solid IMAP solution, which may replace my use of fetchmail. However, a maintainer of OfflineIMAP indicates he is focused on imapfw[1]. So maybe that's one to look into as well. It's not that I'm unhappy with fetchmail, but it doesn't hurt to know what the relative strengths and weaknesses are of the choices available. 0 - http://www.offlineimap.org/ http://www.offlineimap.org/ 1 - http://imapfw.offlineimap.org/ http://imapfw.offlineimap.org/