2 ms·
I have predicted this for a long time (not just me, but a lot of people). The demand for human labor is going down on average, so wages are going down - and h
by EGreg 11y ago
I have predicted this for a long time (not just me, but a lot of people).
The demand for human labor is going down on average, so wages are going down - and have been on a decline since the 70s. Capitalism relies on employers to value their employees for the money to trickle down and the system to work. Our grandfathers used to work for the same employer for decades and got a pension. Today, that loyalty is unheard of from either side. We have the rise of temps and the contractor economy and unemployed living with parents.
Yes, the cost of mass produced consumer goods is going down. So the wage repression is mitigated. With the explosion of consumer credit in the 80s and 90s, the unsustainability of consumer spending was also masked. Now it has come to the fore, in exactly the areas where costs are not going down: rent and real estate. In every major city including NYC and SF, the costs of rent are sky high relative to wages. Wonder why? Look at the rest of the country and it's true too -- the rents are slightly lower but the wages are lower too.
So the predictions are borne out... automation has reduced demand for human labor, reduced wages for the average worker (or they got laid off / became temps), reduced the prices of mass produced goods, but the cost of real estate keeps rising.
- wycx 11y agoCapitalism relies on employers to value their employees for the money to trickle down and the system to work. It is not capitalism but rather neoliberalism/monetarism that propels the trickle-down theory. The time period where grandfathers worked for the same employer and then got a pension coincided with the post-depression/WW2 period of Keyensianism when many western governments pursed full employment economies via fiscal policy. In the period from the early 1970s onwards when neoliberalism/monetarism has been dominant, we have seen falling real wages, the financialisation of the economy (including the consumer credit explosion you describe), governments restricting themselves to managing the economy only through the very blunt tool of monetary policy (i.e. interest rates via a central bank). I would argue that the symptoms we both identify are the result of neoliberal/monetarist policy rather than decreased demand for human labour. If governments still pursued full employment via fiscal policy things would be very different.
- tanker 11y agoHow do you encourage full employment with fiscal policy? Does the concept of full employment imply large corporations hire most of the people or do the fiscal policies also encourage small business and self employment?
- wycx 11y agoIt can be all of the above, plus government employees. An example would be government funding of large infrastructure projects that employ lots of people during construction.
- refurb 11y agoThe demand for human labor is going down on average, so wages are going down - and have been on a decline since the 70s. You have a source for that? If you had said wages were stagnant, I would have believed you, but gone down since the 1970's. That's the opposite of the data I've seen.
- EGreg 11y agoOkay here is some background: http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qOP2V_np2c0 http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qOP2V_np2c0 Show me the data you've seen. The 1970s were the height of wages and unionization, and then globalization (thanks to technology) led to outsourcing. Early physical automation was ok because people all started to sit in front of computers. But now, the mental tasks are being automated away, and that leads to jobs coming back... to robots. Also read this: http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2012/01/stiglitz-depression-201201 http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2012/01/stiglitz-depression-2... Automation is also what led to the Great Depression as we lost primary sector jobs and it took a decade to migrate to the cities and build up the secondary sector, factories, workforce.