2 ms·
Great great article. As far as my memory serves my I do though think that the article is making one claim that is wrong. It was Bach and not Mozart who was ob
by ThomPete 17y ago
Great great article.
As far as my memory serves my I do though think that the article is making one claim that is wrong.
It was Bach and not Mozart who was obsessed with numbers and not phi or fibonacci.
Harmony in western music is based on phi subdivisions of the octave.
Fibonacci is used in design and art quite a lot. the A paper format (A0, A1, A2, A3, A4 etc.) is based on it.
When you see a website that is "pleasing to the eye" that is often (but far from always) based on some interpretation of Fibonacci sequence.
Most probably it's the consistency in proportional difference that is pleasing and not phi in it self.
Phi and f are retrospectively pleasing because they are culturally imposed on us. If you divide an octave in ten (instead of 12) then you get a different division of the octave but it wont feel pleasing to the ear.
Just as the Arabic division of the octave is quite different and doesn't really allow for harmony.
So I think it's premature to just throw it all out and say nonsense. Neither Fiboncci nor Phi are some natural constant but they might be a cultural constant for the west.
Or as Wittgenstein said:
"The faculty of taste cannot create a new structure, it can only make adjustments to one that already exists"
- ThomPete 17y agoWhy the downvote?
- DougBTX 17y agoI've not voted on your comment, but here are a couple of reasons I'm leaving it at zero: * Grammar in the first sentence, the "As far as my" line, is quite garbled for an into to a reasonably long comment. * I can't verify your other claims, but I know A series paper is based on the 1:sqrt(2) ratio, not 1:phi, so I suspect you're falling for the same trap that the article warns against, 0.62 is almost 0.71 right?
- ThomPete 17y agoYeah you are right. My bad. Perhaps the confusion comes from how you would normally try and structure your grid. I am not sure though if 0.71 is too far from 0.62 to be considered close enough. Regarding grammar I unfortunately I can't edit it sorry.