5 ms·
With the same argument, agriculture is important for advanced economies, because no other sector can generate as many jobs. Remember, not too long ago a large m
by adrianN 11y ago
With the same argument, agriculture is important for advanced economies, because no other sector can generate as many jobs. Remember, not too long ago a large majority of the people were farmers.
Eventually we'll have to move away from the notion that everybody needs a job that contributes to GDP.
- ekianjo 11y ago> Eventually we'll have to move away from the notion that everybody needs a job that contributes to GDP. The goal is not maximum employment, The goal is maximum production. Whether that involves more employees is a totally different topic.
- Scarblac 11y agoThe goal should be maximum happiness.
- mryan 11y agoEmployment and production are easy to measure. Happiness, less so.
- Scarblac 11y agoThat's a bit of an odd reason to change the whole goal, isn't it? So we track the kinds of things that we can measure and that we hope correlate with happiness, but we carefully check that they keep doing so. We shouldn't let one of them (like "maximize production") become the end goal itself!
- mryan 11y ago> That's a bit of an odd reason to change the whole goal, isn't it? Having a goal of 'maximising production' is the status quo - I am not proposing any changes. I agree with you that the world would be a better place if our economy was focussed on achieving maximum global happiness, I just wanted to point out why it is easier to focus on an objective, numeric value like production than a subjective feeling like happiness (Gross National Happiness notwithstanding).
- novalis78 11y agoThen let's produce lamborghinis and mansions for everyone and automate healthcare
- mryan 11y agoI'm not sure what point you are making here. It does not appear to have any connection to the point I made.
- ajuc 11y agoLet people move without barriers. Countries will have to compete basing on happiness not production. Happiness will equalize. The only problem - population density is part of happines, so borders should be adjusted for population. Easiest way to do both automaticaly is to let people declare which country their immediate neighborhood belongs to.
- mryan 11y agoI do not think eradicating the concept of national sovereignty is the best solution to the problem. That would certainly decrease the happiness of a lot of people :-)
- icebraining 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_National_Happiness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_National_Happiness
- pygy_ 11y agoHumans may not be needed to maximally produce. Be careful what you wish for.
- adrianN 11y agoSometime in the last century, there was a massive shift from producing what people need to producing needs. I don't think that was a step in the right direction.
- the8472 11y ago> The goal is maximum production Paperclips?
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoAll well and good, but that doesn't address what to do with all the people not working. Take away a man's purpose and you end up with a shell of a man. If you do this at scale, you're going to see a rise in medical (mental and physical health) needs. You'll see crime go up (bored people with nothing to do will fill it with something). You'll see suicides increase (again, purpose). Man needs a purpose for being, plain and simple. So, when we do away with all the jobs through automation and shipping them elsewhere, we'll have to set up community programs where people can find things to do.
- pessimizer 11y ago> Take away a man's purpose and you end up with a shell of a man. This is a religious belief. Also, you're equivocating between purpose and job. edit: my job facilitates any purpose I may have through providing me with money. In every other aspect it hinders me. That's why they pay me and I don't pay them.
- JustSomeNobody 11y ago>This is a religious belief. Is it? >Also, you're equivocating between purpose and job. I'm saying once people have no work, they'll have to have something to do. They can't just stand around all day; it isn't healthy.
- a-priori 11y agoYes it is a religious belief. Whether you realize it or not, what you're describing is the Protestant work ethic imported into North American culture by Puritan settlers from Germanic regions of Europe and Scandinavia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestant_work_ethic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protestant_work_ethic
- Artistry121 11y agoTo question 1 it is definitely not a well founded belief - evolutionarily humans in general have had the purpose of "eat, survive and copulate" - none of which will change in any near term worlds. There may be less to struggle against though.
- ssalazar 11y agoWhose goal?
- fulafel 11y agoGDP as a metric is increasingly divorced from interests of the people.