4 ms·
The last time I made this argument it got like eight upvotes and ten downvotes without any of the naysayers explaining themselves, so I'm going to make it again
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
The last time I made this argument it got like eight upvotes and ten downvotes without any of the naysayers explaining themselves, so I'm going to make it again.
A carbon tax imposed by a majority of industrialized countries would be net profitable for countries that aren't large net petroleum exporters at the expense of countries that are.
The carbon tax reduces consumption (i.e. demand) for petroleum, which reduces its pre-tax market price according to supply and demand. In other words the higher after-tax price of oil causes more people to buy electric cars and build out non-fossil power generation, which means less burning of oil and coal, which means less buying of it.
So you have a $2/gallon tax but the resulting drop in demand reduces the pre-tax price of petroleum by $1/gallon (or whatever), which means you're only actually paying $1/gallon more for gas. Meanwhile you have $2/gallon worth of tax revenue which you can give back to the people paying the gas tax via a negative income tax or whatever you like. The extra $1/gallon is money not paid to Russia and Saudi Arabia, which we get instead.
It's free money at the expense of antagonistic countries. The fact that it also happens to save the world is just a nice side benefit.
- kbenson 11y agoIf you subsidize people buying gas with taxes from buying gas, isn't that a net equilibrium, and people (if perfectly rational) should buy the same amount of gas (since it costs the same in the end)? I understand that some people would buy less because there's an aversion to spending more, or people that just can't afford it in the moment, but I'm not sure it makes sense, economically, as you've explained it.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoThe tax credit is fixed, not based on how much gas you buy. The average person pays $2000 in tax (but the oil now costs $1000 less pre-tax) and then gets a $2000 tax credit. If you burn less oil than average you still get the $2000 credit but pay only $800 in tax, so switching to oil alternatives puts that much more money in your pocket.