4 ms·
This is what I always wondered about. I mean, flash is designed to operate in a keyboard/mouse environment. How would it's event model map to a multitouch model
by mbreese 17y ago
This is what I always wondered about. I mean, flash is designed to operate in a keyboard/mouse environment. How would it's event model map to a multitouch model? I suspect that it could be done, but it would be awkward at best. Also, the biggest argument for flash on the iPhone/ipad has been the large amount of games already available. Well, most (if not all) expect a keyboard and mouse. There is no way they would be able to work unaltered.
- ThomPete 17y agoIsn't most frameworks that deals with GUI designed for keyboard/mouse? Just because a platform allows for multi touch does not mean that the underlying functionality changes. Multi Touch primarily gives you an ability to interact with the platform differently but the functionality it gives you access to is by and large the same. Zoom, rotate etc. Or what am I missing?
- bmelton 17y agoPredominately, you're missing the same thing I missed at first, which is that SO MUCH of Flash works on mouseover -- but how do you have a mouseover event on a touch-only interface?
- ThomPete 17y agoAgain that can be applied to everything that uses mouseover as part of it's interaction flow. Tooltips, Alt Tags, slideshows and so on.
- tjogin 17y agoTooltips aren't crucial to use a webpage the way mouseover and mousemove events are crucial to most flash games.
- ThomPete 17y agoWhat do you mean not crucial? Of course it is. Quite a few online services and applications use it to hide complexity. For instance I am currently working on redesign of a netbank which involves introducing visual overview of your spending. Flash is perfect for that. But for some reason because many games of mouseover event's it's is an argument for why apple shouldn't allow it? Sorry that's not an argument, that's poor reasoning.
- glhaynes 17y agoSpeaking on behalf of users of banking websites: Please don't make your site in Flash.
- tjogin 17y agoWhat I mean is that most flash games require mouseover and mousemove events to be used — or else they're completely void of interactivity — no more useful than a static image. Most web apps, on the other hand, are fully useable without the user ever seeing any tooltip. That's what I mean by crucial. To be honest, I thought it was pretty clear already.
- pietro 17y agoYou're missing that in order to use touch, just about every Flash game out there would have to be rewritten. Flash and its event model are quite flexible, and there's no reason why you shouldn't be able write games for a touch based system in Flash. But you'd have to write them first, and ideally there'd be an event interface specifically for touch, or it would be overly complex.
- ThomPete 17y agoI am aware of that. But that applies to everything out there that relies on mouseover. When the iPad comes along and people will be using it for more complex webbrowsing a lot of web applications/services will have to be rewritten because they rely on mouseover states.
- adolph 17y agoThere is a lot to be said for skating to where the puck will be, rather than where it is right now. For example, at one point in time most games were published on 3.5 inch magnetic floppy disks. The publishing media changed over time and that is no longer the case.
- ryoshu 17y agoYou set up new events that handle low level stroke information or higher level strokes and chords. Multi-touch in Flash is possible; I was doing it three years ago on custom hardware. In some cases games would certainly need to be altered to work with the new events, but the AS3 event system is robust enough that you can write apps that work on multi-touch and non-multi-touch hardware.