3 ms·
The problem I see with this whole conversation about ad blocking is that focuses so much on the blocking part and less so on how it could affect content per se.
by elorant 11y ago
The problem I see with this whole conversation about ad blocking is that focuses so much on the blocking part and less so on how it could affect content per se. I’m of the opinion that ad blocking in the long term could work in benefit of quality content. I mean look at how the landscape is right now. Everyone and their dog can build a crappy site, steal content from major venues, change a title here and a sentence there, apply for AdSense and start monetizing. Why should I give a flying fuck for the sustainability of this model? Content should be original. If that means that 95% of sites out there would disappear I’m fine by that. If it also means that I’d end up paying for content I’m fine by that too. I still pay for paper magazines, I have half a dozen subscriptions to some of them.
What will the advertising industry do? For starters they have to be held accountable if they serve malware. There need to be some strict ruling that will have significant implications. Once we get past that we need to talk about profiling. It’s immoral, period. We don’t like it and I seriously doubt if it’s even working. Once the industry addresses those two issues then we can talk. In the meantime sites could start serving ads from their domains. That could render current ad blocking technology obsolete. It could also make them relevant again, like they used to be before Google took over the industry. In either way they need to start innovating fast, or sit back and whine like spoiled brats while adoption of ad blocking keeps climbing.
- mrweasel 11y ago>We don’t like it and I seriously doubt if it’s even working I think you right, the only place where profiling, if you can call it that, is working, is on Amazon, and it basically only works for books. Most of what we think of as "the advertising industry" isn't exactly advertising anymore. It's a company that will take what you feed them, do some generic processing on it an plaster as many site as possible, big sites if you pay them enough. The amount of incompetent people in the online "advertising" business is staggering. Most of them don't understand how the Internet works. You just get emails with "Hey, put this on your page, it will help us track conversion". Then you review it and realize that their stupid Javascript snippet either break other Javascript, or that their server is to slow to actually handle the requests. Online advertising has become a huge source of revenue to a whole industry that struggles to justify their value. These people will pressure the publishers and tell them that evil ad blockers are the reason their losing money, but that entire business models is broken. It's just a scam, moving money from companies with actual products and services to publishers of questionable content, via equally shady middlemen. It wouldn't be so bad if actual work went into producing high quality ads, published on the right media/site and targeted at the right people.
- elorant 11y agoSo why don't we disrupt the damn thing? I mean by building something better, not breaking it altogether as we do with ad blocking.
- swasheck 11y agoI agree to a certain degree. I'm fine with tasteful, well-placed ads. The problem is that once it became lucrative, content providers binged on ad space such that the remaining real estate for content was overshadowed by that used for advertisements. I _think_ I recall an HN link somewhere that showed some study of how the content:ad ratio has consistently declined, but I can't find the link right now. Long story short, I agree that it could negatively affect content, but it seems like binging on ad revenue has already negatively affected content.
- nsgi 11y agoWhen people worry about the effects of ad blocking, they aren't generally concerned about the future of content farms.
- untog 11y ago> Why should I give a flying fuck for the sustainability of this model? That model? Yeah, screw that. But major news organizations like the New York Times still depend in a huge part on advertising revenue to stay afloat - subscribers alone do not make up the shortfall. So if we want to destroy the content farms we also run the risk of destroying the news organizations that produce the original stories.