9 ms·
I'd rather a simpler solution. You can't accuse non-living property of a crime, you can only seize assets as part of a normal criminal proceeding. And under n
by rootusrootus 11y ago
I'd rather a simpler solution. You can't accuse non-living property of a crime, you can only seize assets as part of a normal criminal proceeding. And under no circumstances can the proceeds from a seizure be given to anybody in the decision-making chain.
- sbuttgereit 11y agoAnd don't forget that it must be returned upon an acquittal in those proceedings.
- kbenson 11y ago> You can't accuse non-living property of a crime, you can only seize assets as part of a normal criminal proceeding. Well, this is the heart of civil forfeiture, and without it there isn't any. Civil forfeiture is also how they confiscate contraband, or anything that is itself illegal to own. I imagine without CF law enforcement would be forced to charge you with a crime to remove illegal property from you. This might be problematic in the case of guns, illegal substances, explosives, etc. I'm not sure about requiring a 16 year old to be charged with a crime for a police officer to take him beer away, so I understand this argument to some degree. It's a case of police discretion being warped into something it wasn't intended to be. > And under no circumstances can the proceeds from a seizure be given to anybody in the decision-making chain. This is common sense, but is wrapped up on the idea of using CF to help fund police departments because the public doesn't want to. Personally, I would like to see the money go towards treatment and counseling for people with problems with drugs, addiction, criminal records and mental illnesses, and community building and outreach programs.
- the_ancient 11y ago>>this is the heart of civil forfeiture, and without it there isn't any Good, there should not be. > It's a case of police discretion being warped into something it wasn't intended to be. Actually it is not, this is exactly what was intended when they passed the laws, I do not know where you get the idea this was about "taking a beer from a 16 year old"
- kbenson 11y agoWithout civil forfeiture, any time the police take something from you, it's theft. Without it, the courts would need to be the ones to deal with this issue, and while I think most of us agree that would yield a fairer judgement, it wouldn't necessarily be timely, and time can matter. For example, CF is used to return stolen good to the owner. It's also used to keep criminals from using the fruits of their crime prior to conviction. Should a bank robber be allowed to use the money from their heist to pay for their defense? Should the embezzler be allowed to transfer the money in question to locations where the government has no jurisdiction? For reasons for civil forfeiture, this[1] might be an interesting read. You don't have to agree with everything in it (I don't), but I believe there are some good points. Here's an excerpt: Forfeiture is also used to abate nuisances and to take the instrumentalities of crime out of circulation. For example, if drug dealers are using a "crack house" to sell drugs to children as they pass by on the way to school, the building is a danger to the health and safety of the neighborhood. Under the forfeiture laws, we can shut it down. If a boat or truck is being used to smuggle illegal aliens across the border, we can forfeit the vessel or vehicle to prevent its use time and again for the same purpose. The same is true for an airplane used to fly cocaine from Peru into Southern California, or a printing press used to mint phony $100 bills. 1: http://www.fed-soc.org/publications/detail/forfeiture-is-reasonable-and-it-works http://www.fed-soc.org/publications/detail/forfeiture-is-rea...
- simplemath 11y agoAh yes, thanks for invoking "save the children" and the farcical War on Drugs. Throw the baby out with the bathwater r.e. civil forfeiture. Civil forfeiture victimizes far more people than it helps protect people and society at large from bad actors using ill-gotten gains. In fact, I'd say that the bad actors using the ill-gotten gains are overwhelmingly LE itself.
- kbenson 11y ago> Ah yes, thanks for invoking "save the children" and the farcical War on Drugs. That's from an excerpt from a document I referenced. I already noted I didn't agree with everything in it, but there were more examples that just that in the excerpt. > Civil forfeiture victimizes far more people than it helps protect people and society at large from bad actors using ill-gotten gains. That would be an interesting point in the argument if true. Can you substantiate that?
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> Civil forfeiture is also how they confiscate contraband, or anything that is itself illegal to own. If something is illegal to own, then there should be no difficulties charging the owner with a crime. > I imagine without CF law enforcement would be forced to charge you with a crime to remove illegal property from you. Exactly. > I'm not sure about requiring a 16 year old to be charged with a crime for a police officer to take him beer away Just like an officer can choose not to write up a ticket, they can tell a first-time offender "Throw away the beer right now and I'll let your parents deal with this; otherwise I'll have to charge you." That doesn't require civil forfeiture.
- kbenson 11y ago> If something is illegal to own, then there should be no difficulties charging the owner with a crime. Do we want the law to be this inflexible? It sounds good initially, but I would rather the starving man have the bread he stole gently taken by the police and returned to the owner, and sent on his way (hopefully with some help), than to be arrested. Without civil forfeiture, this turn of events would require the police to either arrest the starving man, or break the law themselves to take the bread. CF is a way for the police to use their discretion to right situations, and to prevent additional harm to victims (such as preventing property from being destroyed, used or spent after the criminal is apprehended but before conviction). What about the case of stolen property, and the misuse of hiding of it prior to conviction but after arrest? It does the victim little good if the property stolen is disposed of or hidden after arrest. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for massive reform for the law in these cases, I just think there are cases where it's useful, and careful consideration should be given as to whether we need to keep some portion of it intact, or remove it altogether, and the consequences of that choice. Edit: Okay, ignore the stolen bread and kid with beer examples. They aren't well thought out, and are distracting from the other examples and and points, which I think deserve attention. I'm only leaving it here because I'm loathe to remove something people are responding to, even if it reflects poorly on me. :/
- swyman 11y ago> Without civil forfeiture, this turn of events would require the police to either arrest the starving man, or break the law themselves to take the bread. Or tell him he'd be arrested if he didn't hand over the bread...
- DougBTX 11y ago> I imagine without CF law enforcement would be forced to charge you with a crime to remove illegal property from you. CF isn't generally used to take illegal goods, but to take otherwise legal goods. For example in a drink driving stop, they may charge the car with a drink driving offence.
- kbenson 11y agoThat's not true. CF is how assets are seized prior to conviction, including stolen good to be given back to the rightful owner[1]. CF has a lot of problems, but let's not ignore that it can, and has been used to good effect in the past as well. I doubt doing so will lead us to a better outcome. 1: http://www.fed-soc.org/publications/detail/forfeiture-is-reasonable-and-it-works http://www.fed-soc.org/publications/detail/forfeiture-is-rea...
- ascorbic 11y agoSurely stolen goods still belong to the original owner. Why would they need CF to give it back?
- kbenson 11y agoWhile easy to reason about morally and with common sense, the law is a bit more strict in that in defining when something is or is not a possession, and until proven otherwise by a court, if someone claims property is theirs, to remove it without consent is theft. There may be plenty of cases where it's obvious who owns what, but it would be illegal to rectify prior to judgement if the perpetrator continues to claim ownership. For example, a bike with a serial number and documentation. If the thief claims the bike was thrown away, and you claim it was locked up and there were no witnesses, then without CF you might have to wait for a judgement before the bike is removed from the perpetrator and given back to you. With Cf, the police might make a judgement that you deserve the bike until judgement. Of course even this situation is open to abuse and mistakes...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jimrandomh 11y ago> I imagine without CF law enforcement would be forced to charge you with a crime to remove illegal property from you. This might be problematic in the case of guns, illegal substances, explosives, etc. I see no problem with guns, illegal substances, and explosives being a separately-delineated legal category, allowing them to be seized while not allowing cars, computers and other private property to be seized. > I'm not sure about requiring a 16 year old to be charged with a crime for a police officer to take him beer away, so I understand this argument to some degree. It's a case of police discretion being warped into something it wasn't intended to be. I don't think that would be handled through civil forfeiture law, either. They'd just pour it out.
- kbenson 11y ago> I see no problem with guns, illegal substances, and explosives being a separately-delineated legal category, allowing them to be seized while not allowing cars, computers and other private property to be seized. That would be a refinement to CF, where it only applies to specific items, not the complete abolishment of it. There is the problematic case of money, and being able to return it to the rightful owner. > I don't think that would be handled through civil forfeiture law, either. They'd just pour it out. It's a poor example. I'll freely admit that. The point was to show that any time the police take something from you without a conviction and without CF, it would be real theft, under the law, not theft in all but name, which we have now. In some cases that's good, and in some I think it's not.
- tlrobinson 11y ago> I'm not sure about requiring a 16 year old to be charged with a crime for a police officer to take him beer away Officer: "Pour out that beer immediately or I will arrest you"
- LordKano 11y agoI'm not sure about requiring a 16 year old to be charged with a crime for a police officer to take him beer away, so I understand this argument to some degree. Why confiscate the beer? Dump it out and return the bottles. The officer is just helping the kid to come into compliance with the law.
- anon4 11y agoAlso, every item taken must be written down, the list signed by the officer overseeing the raid and by the accused and a copy given to the accused.
- sliverstorm 11y agounder no circumstances can the proceeds from a seizure be given to anybody in the decision-making chain. That's how it used to be. Once upon a time, if I recall, the money went to the federal justice department. But in 1984 the law was tweaked to "equitably share" the proceeds with the enforcement departments that made the bust.
- X86BSD 11y agoI'll make this even simpler, no VICTIM, no CRIME. Unless you can produce a victim no crime has been committed. Follow this simple rule and most of this illegal, immoral tyrannical shit stops.
- pdabbadabba 11y agoSo, for example, DUI should be legal unless someone gets hurt? What about tax evasion? Can the government itself be counted as a victim? If so, then I think this exception might well swallow your rule...
- ascagnel_ 11y ago"The People" (as represented by the government) would be a victim in a tax evasion case; they're harmed because tax revenues that would be put toward civic services were not paid.
- X86BSD 11y agoAs noted taxation is theft. Doubly so if it's not a voluntary contract. For instance, sales tax is voluntary. I choose wether or not to make a purchase. I decide if I want to pay that tax. Income tax, is not. It's pure theft. We never had one for the first 100 years. "The people" are a group. Groups do not have rights. Individuals have rights. There is no such thing as group rights. That's why we have a lot of the problems we have because we keep putting people into groups.
- pdabbadabba 11y agoIt seems to me that theft is the unlawful, involuntary taking of property. Just like how murder is not just killing, but an unlawful killing. So, while you might think that taxation is the moral equivalent of theft, I'm not sure it makes sense to say that they are literally the same thing. And it certainly adds nothing useful to a discussion with people who, as you surely are aware, have heard this tired phrase many times before and have good reason for disagreeing with it. What do you make of these examples? Let's say that I run over your leg with my car, and you successfully sue me for damages. I have no liquid assets with which to pay your judgment. Therefore, you obtain a lien against my boat, seize it, and sell the boat to help satisfy the judgment. Is this theft? Should this be legal? Or what about confiscations of property for reasons other than taxation or the satisfaction of judgments? For example, it seems to me it would be a sensible policy to confiscate automatic firearms from people who have been convicted of multiple violent felonies. Would that be theft? Or what if the state can prove, at trial, that your private jet was purchased with the proceeds of a protection racket. Can it be seized and sold to compensate your victims, or would that be theft? I should add that I also don't see how your distinction between sales tax and income tax makes any sense. The sale and the income are both voluntary--the tax is not. If your point is that the underlying behavior is voluntary, I'm not sure how that distinguishes the cases. Earning an income is no less voluntary than making a purchase (though surely some purchases are more voluntary than others -- just like income). How about if we made it a condition on any purchase that you agreed to pay an income tax? Would that resolve your concern? I'm guessing it wouldn't, though I'm not sure I can see why, except that you like sales taxes for some reason but don't like income taxes.