2 ms·
Richard Gabriel has a nice write-up on this, well worth reading especially if you're in the sputtering 'zomg this is SO dumb' camp. It's also a much quicker rea
by pvg 17y ago
Richard Gabriel has a nice write-up on this, well worth reading especially if you're in the sputtering 'zomg this is SO dumb' camp. It's also a much quicker read than the entirety of the Stanford page.
http://www.dreamsongs.com/Searle.html http://www.dreamsongs.com/Searle.html
"Searle's argument is subtle in a way that seems to confuse intelligent readers. "
- Herring 17y ago> Most of the critics of Searle's argument fail to respond directly to his points. This is actually not all that surprising in that most of the critics are scientists and Searle's argument is philosophical, but it means that doing a point by point critique of the argument is unlikely to be very useful. Well now, that says something about philosophy's relevance to science. > Many people consider the concept of gender inseparable from its fleshly and biological origin and nature. And many people don't. The argument is just philosophical, what's the big deal?