7 ms·
while "war on magnets" may sound silly at first, it is hard to not see the rationale behind it. https://www.aap.org/en-us/advocacy-and-policy/federal-advocacy/
by trhway 11y ago
while "war on magnets" may sound silly at first, it is hard to not see the rationale behind it.
https://www.aap.org/en-us/advocacy-and-policy/federal-advocacy/Pages/AAP-Alerts-Pediatricians-to-Dangers-of-Magnet-Ingestions.aspx https://www.aap.org/en-us/advocacy-and-policy/federal-advoca...
" Although these products are labeled and designed for adults, they can easily find their way into the hands and mouths of children."
Also a fact sheet from the North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology and Nutrition -
http://www.naspghan.org/files/documents/pdfs/advocacy/2013/NASPGHAN%20Magnet%20Ingestion%20Fact%20Sheet%202013.pdf http://www.naspghan.org/files/documents/pdfs/advocacy/2013/N...
I mean nobody keeps rat poison in the open on the desk. If you look at statistics (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24791640 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24791640 - quarter of the cases require intervention, and half of those cases are small magnets) the swallowing of those magnets somewhat comparable to swallowing of a rat poison (out of about 10K+ cases/years, about 1/3 is treated medically).
And there are those fury curious vacuums that only look like a labrador or a poodle - one can only hope that their owners pay enough attention.
- dublinben 11y ago>" Although these products are labeled and designed for adults, they can easily find their way into the hands and mouths of children." By that argument, any and all potentially dangerous products must be banned. No power tools, firearms, knives, lighters, or small pieces of matter may be legally sold or possessed in the United States.
- trhway 11y agoman, i understand your logic, and i many cases i follow it myself. In this case the court is on your side, so not sure that me have much new to explore, i just wanted to mention the [failed] arguments of the other side that i'm sympathetic to in this case. I'm not against those magnets personally and think they should be available, it is just the situation that millions people have them lying around is really a danger. Not sure what can be done to make the situation great for everybody. At least in case of firearms, while they are available, they aren't just lying around easily accessible to children. Power tools, knives, lighters - it has been always, even in childhood, pretty much clear how they do the damage and how to handle them safely. Imagine though a power tool with non-widely known, say surprising, mode of injuring people, and i bet we'd see a bunch of such new injuries and probably the tool will be banned. And this one http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/03/florida-mom-facebook-child-shooting-accident http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2016/03/florida-mom-face... . Not for debating the 2nd (i myself think that the language of the 2nd is clear in actually granting one freedom to have even nukes). Just find it very illustrative that while firearms should be available (as 2nd states), some people just shouldn't have it. Again, have no idea how to implement it.
- simoncion 11y ago> ...it is just the situation that millions people have them lying around is really a danger. 24 incidents per year [0] (or -assuming only one million sets are out there- one incident per ~41,600 sets out there) doesn't seem like much of a danger. For comparison this [2] leads me to calculate that there are ~141 serious accidental poison exposures per 41,600 children out there. [3] By all means, levy a serious penalty for the importation, production, or sale of inadequately or improperly labelled SREM magnet sets. But the actual danger of said sets really appears to be overstated by the CPSC. [0] https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2014/10/03/2014-23341/final-rule-safety-standard-for-magnet-sets#h-16 https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2014/10/03/2014-233... [1] [1] Remember that the ALJ didn't find the CPSC's much larger injury estimates to be credible. [2] http://www.poison.org/poison-statistics-national http://www.poison.org/poison-statistics-national [3] Poison control centers report 42.6 exposures per 1000 kids 6 and younger. NPDS reports that 8% of all reported poison exposures resulted in a moderate, or major effect. So, 42.60.0841.6. This isn't the right way to answer the question "How many young kids are seriously injured by poison exposure?", but it's certainly not a bad way to get an estimate.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- NeutronBoy 11y ago> No power tools, firearms, knives, lighters, or small pieces of matter These things are not marketed as toys to small children.
- abstrakraft 11y agoneither are Zen magnets
- mc32 11y agoThe main difference is more that small children often put small objects in their mouths, toy or not. Most tools, knives, etc. are stowed away from the reach of children, these small magnets can be used on refrigerators or desks, etc, things these children readily have access to and frequent and consequently could wrongly ingest them.
- simoncion 11y agoAs the ALJ found, the problem isn't that the magnets may pose a hazard when ingested, the problem is the possible lack of sufficient labelling, instruction, and up-front warning about the hazards of such magnets. Why do people make tools, knives, or corrosive chemicals inaccessible to those who don't have enough sense to take care when handling such objects? Because they are forewarned about the dangers of said objects. Moreover, the ALJ failed to find any significant evidence that the adults who are purchasing these magnets are being any more reckless with them than they are any other hazardous object they might have in their house. From the article: > “The Agency was unable to sufficiently and credibly correlate any SREM injuries directly to Zen Magnets or Neoballs. The lack of credible evidence here is telling.” And regarding the CPSC’s (Epidemiology) Elephant in the Room, that easily disproven (yet commonly repeated by media) CPSC injury estimate of 2,900 “magnet set” ingestions from 2009 to 2013: “These numbers are insignificant to show any specific, identifiable population, particularly given the mass amount of magnets purchased and already on the market.”
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoNeither are the magnets. Where did you get that idea?
- tptacek 11y agoNo. It's not the magnets that were being banned. It was the packaging and marketing of the magnets.
- simoncion 11y agoI might be reading this wrong, but it seems that there's an import ban on these magnets? From the first item in the FAQ in the article: "Even though Zen Magnets and the included warnings have been found to be without flaw, there is still a nationwide import ban." Edit: This [0] is linked to elsewhere in the discussion. It seems to support the assertion that there's an import ban. [0] https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2014/10/03/2014-23341/final-rule-safety-standard-for-magnet-sets https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2014/10/03/2014-233...
- makomk 11y agoThe danger with small magnets like this is that, just like you did in this comment, people simply don't understand that they're more dangerous than other "small pieces of matter" no matter how many warnings the companies put on the packaging. Most other small items, even fairly sharp ones, generally pass through the digestive system without incident, but magnets stick together and trap intestinal tissue causing tissue necrosis and death within days without surgery. Lest you think I'm singling you out somehow, every discussion I've seen on this issue has unintentionally demonstrated the complete ineffectiveness of the labelling.
- AlgorithmicTime 11y agoThe job of the government is not to protect people from any small risk, it's to protect them from malevolence.
- shalmanese 11y agoHere's what most people don't understand about these magnets: Once you play with them for a bit, you realize there's only a very limited number of things you can do with them. Pretty quickly, you discover one of the limited number of things is stuff like making fake ear rings or nose rings etc. If you count the number of thin skin folds on the human body, there's only a couple (ear lobes, nostril, cheek, tongue, maybe eyelid and various parts of the genitalia). A significant portion of those are an orifice into the digestive tract. What you find happens is that kids start off making ear rings and then graduate onto making tongue rings and the tongue is just thick enough that the attachment is weak and it presents a high risk of swallowing. Here's the second thing that most people fail to appreciate: The CSPS's main concern was not the absolute level of danger, it was the how non-obvious the threat model is. There are plenty of things that are far more dangerous on an absolute level but are allowed because most people understand the risk model and can take appropriate steps to mitigate. If you asked a thousand people who previously knew nothing about the magnets, what they thought the main danger was, people would talk about the potential choking hazard or the chemicals in the lining maybe being toxic but I bet virtually nobody would ever think about intestinal pinching. You could have your child swallow one of these magnets every week and see them come out fine and be completely blase and then the one week they swallow two, they're suddenly in need of life threatening surgery. I don't have any strong opinions on whether these things should be banned or not but I think the CSPSs case is a lot stronger that what's commonly presented.
- WillPostForFood 11y agoI have a very hard time seeing the rationale. There has been a single death attributed to ingestion of magnets. The ban is based on media fear mongering and the general pathetic parenting that can acknowledge to risk and take no responsibility for danger. 87 toddlers drown in the bathtub in the bathtub every year. 350 drown in swimming pools. That accidents happen doesn't mean things are defective and should be banned.
- jwr 11y agoI have a friend whose child died as a result of swallowing two magnets. The child wasn't even small — school-age. Made a bet with friends that he'll be able to swallow a magnet, and did. Then repeated the same thing next day (this is what's fatal, as it leads to intestinal pinching). Nobody knew. When symptoms started appearing and they got to a hospital, it was already too late. While I wouldn't go as far as preventing the sale of magnets, education is definitely important. People should be aware of the extreme and silent danger that small, spherical, and easy to swallow magnets pose to their children. As your comment shows, many are not aware.
- simoncion 11y ago> While I wouldn't go as far as preventing the sale of magnets, education is definitely important. Good thing that every reputable seller of such magnets plasters the outside of the packaging with warnings like "Not for children!" "Not a child's toy!", and includes very frank, easy-to-understand language about the potential hazards of ingestion of said magnets. That story about that kid is a tragic story. It's more tragic that the warnings attached to and included in the packaging surrounding the magnets didn't make their way to the kid who chose to swallow the magnets and the friends who took him up on his stupid bet. > As your comment shows, many are not aware. That's reading a lot into his comment. If you read the last couple of sentences of his comment, it's clear that he's talking about dangerous stuff. One can infer from this that he understands that strong magnets can also be dangerous under certain circumstances. Just because you're unaware of any deaths from a hazardous activity doesn't mean that you're unaware that an activity is hazardous. You dig? If anything, it's more a signal that the fatality or grievous injury rate from that activity is rather low.
- omgwin 11y agoThe thing is the CPSC is not killing the demand for the magnets. There are a billion places you can still purchase them online. In fact you can purchase buckyballs in their original packaging at better prices than before from Chinese companies who are simply ripping off the IP of a dead company. The war on magnets faces the same problem as the war on drugs. And similarly, the solution is education, not prohibition.
- easytiger 11y agoThe US government consider magnets unsafe and bans them, but not guns? Guns are just fine but a subset of small bits of metal are not fine. In the USA, where in 2015 43 children under three years old shot someone or themselves with a gun.* * http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/11932821/toddler-shooting-gun-controls-america.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/1... Someone needs to take a long hard look at themselves.
- hga 11y agoEveryone old enough knows that guns are dangerous (ADDED: and we in the US gun community put a LOT of effort into this, e.g. https://eddieeagle.nra.org/ https://eddieeagle.nra.org/ and have decreased fatal gun accidents from ~800 to ~600 per year in a period when both the population and number of guns owned by it increased by very roughly 50%). Very few know that swallowing two or more small magnets can result in death in a few days, even with medical treatment, especially if the treatment is "too late". That's very much unlike other "small bits of metal", to which I'd include small ammunition (although the commonly unplated lead bullets in .22 LR ammo would add a lead exposure threat). And then there's the little matter of the 2nd Amendment, we have no Constitutionally enshrined right to keep and bear small magnets, which are also fantastically less useful than guns. For that matter, in the 1970's heyday of US gun control, the CPSC was explicitly banned from the area of firearms and ammo. This is not unique, there are many other things like "tobacco, motor vehicles, pesticides, aircraft, aircraft engines and boats" (http://www.nssf.org/newsroom/writers/guide/regulations.cfm http://www.nssf.org/newsroom/writers/guide/regulations.cfm) where the regulation is done by other units of the government, generally ones with domain knowledge. E.g. pesticides touch on at least three areas, safety to those handling and using them, plus food and environmental safety, that's more like the remit of OSHA (which can cover the much smaller consumer uses) plus the FDA and EPA.
- extra88 11y ago> in a period when both the population and number of guns owned by it increased by very roughly 50% An increase in the number of guns owned is deceptive. The percentage of Americans who own a gun and the percentage of households that contain a gun have been decreasing, I think from about half of households in the seventies to about a third today (NRA point to different research that shows less of a decline). The number of guns owned has increased because some people who already have a gun buy more, sometimes many more.