4 ms·
I'm tired of arguing about CO2. Let's make the Republican argument for a carbon tax. Buying oil enriches countries antagonistic to the US. Iran, Saudi Arabia,
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
I'm tired of arguing about CO2. Let's make the Republican argument for a carbon tax.
Buying oil enriches countries antagonistic to the US. Iran, Saudi Arabia, Russia, Venezuela. Oil is a global commodity. If we use less oil then those countries will lose twice: Once because they're selling fewer barrels of oil and then again because, with less demand, pre-tax price per barrel goes down.
This also means we get free money at the expense of those countries. If we enter into a treaty with Europe and China to each put a $2/gallon tax on oil, that does not make gas go from $2 to $4, because the tax will reduce consumption (as intended), which reduces demand, which lowers prices. So instead of paying $2 of which $2 goes to the bad guys, you pay $3 of which $2 goes to Uncle Sam and $1 goes to the bad guys. Then that's $2 we can use to cut other taxes, $1 of which came from the bad guys. So not only is this revenue neutral, it's effectively a tax cut -- you pay $1 extra for gas and then pay $2 less in income tax. American taxpayers end up with more money in their pockets at the expense of Russia and Iran. And the higher we make the gas tax the more it reduces demand which transfers even more money from antagonistic foreign countries to US taxpayers.
Somebody tell me why CO2 even matters when carbon tax justifies itself regardless.
- pitchka 11y agoSimple way of burning less oil is taking subsidies from all the industries that get them, like meat, dairy and eggs. Luxury foods are really the biggest greenhouse gas footprint. Cows produce more than 60% of our methane footprint, and on a 20 year scale methane is around 80 times more potent than CO2 for global warming. Taxes can be a solution but you have to take subsidies too.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoMethane is very potent but there is also much less emitted than CO2. https://www3.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/sources/agriculture.html https://www3.epa.gov/climatechange/ghgemissions/sources/agri... According to that link agriculture is 9% of CO2-equivalent emissions while electricity and transportation are 58%. Which isn't to say nothing should be done about agriculture, but it isn't the bulk of the problem, and it isn't what motivates climate change deniers.
- pitchka 11y ago9% is unfortunately underestimate. http://www.fao.org/docrep/010/a0701e/a0701e00.HTM http://www.fao.org/docrep/010/a0701e/a0701e00.HTM Here's an 18% estimate while transportation is 13%. Here's a 51% estimate, trumping everything else. http://www.worldwatch.org/node/6294 http://www.worldwatch.org/node/6294 Some hypothesise that the footprint is even larger. Given the fact that we have to produce food for around 100 billion animals yearly (where a significant amount of these animals weighs more than 250lbs it's not surprising it takes a lot of energy to do that. Machines like cars, planes are on the other hand pretty efficient. Unlike animal bodies.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoYou're comparing 18% world-wide to 9% in the US. Both of those numbers sound right. People drive more miles and use more electricity per capita in the US than in BRIC countries. The 51% number is silly. First they count "livestock respiration" as a source of CO2 but that CO2 came from the atmosphere during the last year via plants the animals ate, which they even point out and then try to hand wave away. Then they count land use (i.e. natural forest converted for livestock), which is a serious problem in Brazil and Asia but not the US. Then they argue that the factor used for methane should be higher than the one FAO uses because methane has a shorter half life in the atmosphere than CO2, but that's a double edged sword. We could get a more immediate effect by reducing methane emissions but not reducing CO2 emissions takes longer to recover from than not reducing methane emissions. It's an argument that methane and CO2 are different and we need to reduce both, not an argument that we should reduce methane instead of CO2. And then they point out some miscellaneous factors. Some of them are just silly, like meat requires refrigeration, as if people are going to stop having refrigerators in the alternative. And most of the real ones apply world-wide but not in the US, e.g. FAO's numbers are old and livestock production is now higher world-wide but not in the US, the baseline was Minnesota and third world practices are less efficient, etc. So the EPA's 9% still sounds about right for the US. But third world countries might want to consider growing more vegetables.
- pitchka 11y ago
- MooMooMilkParty 11y agoWhile you are correct that methane is quite potent, when discussing climatological effects it's not as important as CO2. Especially when discussing ice sheets and sea level rise, the long term (1000+ year) effects are what's likely to reduce Greenland and Antarctica to points where feedbacks will prohibit their regrowth (thus dooming them to complete melt and us to deal with the unfortunate side effects). Again, not disagreeing in any way, just looking to provide some context in relation to the subject matter in the original post. In fact, I think climate change and environmental stewardship are issues that go hand in hand and should definitely be taken more seriously.
- jabagawee 11y agoI don't have an opinion yet on a carbon tax or politics, but I can't agree with oil-producing countries suffering a double loss in lower sales and lower prices. The overly-simplified version of supply-vs-demand states that with constant supply, prices are lowered to raise demand. Thus, it's only a single loss there.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoWhat makes you think supply is unaffected by price? If that were true then we should clearly impose a 99.9% revenue tax because supply would be unaffected.
- dredmorbius 11y agoThe language parent post used may be imprecise, but the effect is largely what oil extractors are now seeing. Global oil prices have fallen due to demand descruction. Total quantity of oil consumed is down as well. Revenues, as P * Q, are down. It's a compound effect. Saying that both supply and demand have fallen is incorrect in an economist's sense as to an economist these are functions. Shifting one function (usually expressed as a "curve") moves along the other curve, even without a change in that function. Confusing, I know.