3 ms·
I think the real point of the article is that almost all of the technologies at our disposal are good enough. We spend endless time debating Ruby vs Python, RoR
by jdietrich 17y ago
I think the real point of the article is that almost all of the technologies at our disposal are good enough. We spend endless time debating Ruby vs Python, RoR vs Django and navel gazing about Lisp or Haskell or Smalltalk, but how often do we talk about users? Keep a tally yourself and I think you'll see my point - I counted more HN articles in the past week about Haskell than about users.
I would expect that the majority of us here at HN can easily build stable, reasonably scalable applications quite easily. I would expect that far fewer of us really understand the needs, desires and abilities of the average user. To me, it seems ridiculous that we continue to worry about marginal, incremental improvements in the technology when it is readily apparent that "technically better" solutions are easily beaten in the market by solutions that resonate better with users.
To use your architecture analogy, few architects worry about whether or not a house will stay up, because they have mature processes and frameworks in place to guarantee the soundness of the design. The real work of architects, the part that separates the likes of Foster and Gehry from everyone else, is of aesthetics and usability. What makes an architect great is not their ability to build cheaper or stronger or bigger buildings, but their ability to build beautiful and elegant ones. We have a great deal to learn from them.
- sthomps 17y agoThank you for that wonderful response. The analogy about the architects is spot on. The technology debate is always raging about which platform and language to use. The people present in the tech world can easily forget about the users with all of the technology present. The last statement in your second paragraph is especially wise, and the ability to resonate with users is the absolute key.
- rue 17y ago> I think the real point of the article is that almost all > of the technologies at our disposal are good enough. We > spend endless time debating Ruby vs Python, RoR vs Django > and navel gazing about Lisp or Haskell or Smalltalk, but > how often do we talk about users? Frankly, I do not see any shortage of talk about "users" or "delivering" or any other of hundreds of similar terms. I think this line of reasoning overlooks some pretty crucial factors: - Arguing about X vs. Y beyond a certain point often has nothing to do with "productivity" or some other undefinable metric. It is entertainment. Not ha-ha entertainment, but something to pass the time - trading quips, debating and so on. - New paradigms, languages, frameworks and applications - as well as hardware and architecture - certainly affect users. Some directly, some by providing developers the ability to concentrate on the essence rather than the unnecessary boilerplate obstacles. It often seems that the people writing the "stop language wars" posts and the like are the ones most emotionally invested in the topic. > To use your architecture analogy, few architects worry > about whether or not a house will stay up, because they > have mature processes and frameworks in place to > guarantee the soundness of the design. Yeah, and those processes did not just spring up from nothing. There have been centuries, millennia, of development - and you can be sure there were more than a few "pyramid vs. cube" and "vaulted vs. flat" debates in there.
- aswanson 17y agoI've thought about this on a parallel track. It seems to me that each iteration of a technology makes it easier to create and deploy, until it reaches a point where the only thing that matters are aesthetic capabilities.