4 ms·
>Right, it's not the average case we're discussing here. But I think we can both agree that wrecking a water table in a geographic area of significant size (for
by SilasX 11y ago
>Right, it's not the average case we're discussing here. But I think we can both agree that wrecking a water table in a geographic area of significant size (for example) would qualify as "extreme."
No, we can't. In the context of the specific point you were making, extreme means "no feasible amount of money could undo the damage". That's not true of damage to a water table, which can be remediated with a feasible amount of money.
>... I'm just saying we should ban drunk driving.
No, the point here is that, if drunk driving's effects were as uncountably bad as you claim the potential environmental damage is, we should ban driving, because the effect would wipe out all the benefit of driving, since the insurance cost would make it infeasible. But that's absurd, so we must conclude that your estimates of the harm size are as well.
Remember, you're the one arguing that the extreme cases dominate the risk calculation (to the point of uninsurability), not me!
- kafkaesq 11y agoNo, we can't [agree about large-scale water table damage being remediable with feasible amounts of money]. Well, we disagree then. As to the other stuff -- it seems you're doubling down on extremification techniques, attributing words ("uncountably bad") to me that aren't mine. All I can say is I don't find that line of reasoning helpful, and I don't know what to say to it.
- SilasX 11y agoThere are no "extremification" techniques; it's just that you made a very specific claim about the nature of environmental risks, that such harms are typically (at their worst) so bad as to be uninsurable. My point is that this claim cuts both ways -- in order for the environmental damage of industrial disasters to be that bad (above the ~$1 trillion that a reinsurance network could cover), it would also have to be so bad as to justify banning most classes of industrial activity -- not allowing them even with regulation. Since you probably don't believe that, then you're probably overstating the mangitude of this tail risk, and dismissing its applicability to your own alternative. (Remember, regulation doesn't turn off the extreme events; it's just one way to reduce their likelihood.) Which technique do you think that argument is unhelpfully using?
- kafkaesq 11y agoIt's just that you made a very specific claim about the nature of environmental risks, that such harms are typically (at their worst) so bad as to be uninsurable. "typically (at their worst)"? I'm not even sure what you mean by that. (I have some guesses at what you might be getting at, but they also point to things I didn't say, either). In order for the environmental damage of industrial disasters to be that bad (above the ~$1 trillion that a reinsurance network could cover), it would also have to be so bad as to justify banning most classes of industrial activity. (1) I don't agree (nor do I think most people would agree) that all environmental or human disasters have measurable impact (let alone have a dollar value -- even a very high one -- which would suffice to repair or compensate for the loss the incur). (2) The second half of your statement does not follow from the first. Which technique do you think that argument is unhelpfully using? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reductio_ad_absurdum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reductio_ad_absurdum
- SilasX 11y ago>"typically (at their worst)"? >I'm not even sure what you mean by that. Then review the original usage, which should have made it clear -- I was distinguishing operations where (I claim) the worst case is insurable from the cases where it isn't. I remarked that the worst case is rarely uninsurable, and gave the example of nuclear operations (which means nuclear power and nuclear weapons). So, typically (across the set of environment-risking things), the worst case (within one of those things) is not beyond the reach of insurance. Sorry if that whole "typical extreme" thing threw you for a loop, but I thought it was clear from context. Let me know if you know of a better way to communicate this concept. You seem to be deeply familiar with these kinds of considerations, so I bet you have one. >(1) I don't agree (nor do I think most people would agree) that all environmental or human disasters have measurable impact (let alone have a dollar value -- even a very high one -- which would suffice to repair or compensate for the loss the incur). Well, then you've inserted infinities in your model, which fundamentally breaks things and renders further debate pointless. The moment you say "this outcome is so bad that it dominates all other outcomes", then even small probabilities of it are unacceptable -- the Pascal's Wager dynamic. But that equally cuts against regulatory approaches, and it's not a reason to favor top-down regulation vs the insurance system advocated in the thread. Generally speaking, the moment you refuse to quantify the damage, it's no longer in the reach of reasonable debate. "This thing is infinitely valuable" makes for nice platitudes, but not sound policy. >Reductio ad absurdum It's valid to point out how someone's claim implies an absurdity they disagree with :-p Certainly, you can dispute that the implication follows, but I'm not sure where you're coming from with a categorical dismissal.