7 ms·
Microsoft Announces Converter for Bringing Win32 Apps to the Windows Store
- bradleyjg 11y agoWhat ever happened to programs? Was there something about that word that terribly offended people? Too hard to type out? Is 'app' soon going to be replaced by some kind of pictogram? Enquiring minds want to know.
- UK-AL 11y agoLaziness?
- guardian5x 11y agoApp is shorter than Application or Program. Language evolves as well.
- jamesdwilson 11y agoApp implies microsoft gets a monopoly on control and distribution (as well as revocation), ie app store, ie walled garden. It also implies you should expect it to not be open source, and you should expect to pay at least $0.99 for it.
- wlesieutre 11y agoYou can distribute universal Windows apps outside the Windows Store.
- ant6n 11y agoYou mean programs?
- wlesieutre 11y agoNo, I mean apps. I'm just as lazy as anybody else, and I don't see a need to use an older word with an extra syllable and a bunch of baggage just to show off that I was using computers before the iPhone came out. If they were distributed as .programx files instead of .appx files, maybe you'd have a point.
- ant6n 11y agoSo when the IPhone came out, the word 'program' was changed to 'app'?
- grokys 11y agoEven before the iPhone came out, people used the abbreviation "app" for "application". Source: I was around then ;)
- ant6n 11y agoBut did they use "app" instead of "program"?
- wlesieutre 11y agoTrue, especially with OS X having .app file extensions. I still called them "Applications" more often than not though.
- ant6n 11y agoOh, so it's like a Mac thing. So why do we have to call Windows programs 'App'?
- icebraining 11y agoIt's not a Mac-only thing, it has been used on Linux and Windows for decades. http://www.drdobbs.com/windows/windows-apps-and-exception-handlers/184409706 http://www.drdobbs.com/windows/windows-apps-and-exception-ha...
- protomyth 11y agoIf your customers check a setting called “side-loading” in "Updates & Security" under "For developers" with a fairly scary warning, then yes you can sell outside the Windows Store.
- madspindel 11y agoNope. Now you can double-click the appx file. Demonstrated on Build keynote.
- protomyth 11y agoWell, that's a whole lot nicer than their website is currently telling me. I did look for updated instructions as this has been a bit of issue with contractor supplied software.
- anonymfus 11y agoThese settings are about digital signatures of applications.
- mrec 11y agoYes, they've been trailing that for a while. Do you know if there's any kind of legally-binding commitment to keep this option open, or might this be a temporary thing while they try to get some traction for the platform?
- wlesieutre 11y agoI'm sure it's not legally binding, but neither is Apple's letting people run unsigned applications or even signed applications from outside the app store. MS seems pretty serious about trying to get developers on board with their platform. I can't imagine them reversing course on this, especially with "Tim Sweeney is wrong about everything, UWP is an open platform" being a recurring subtext of the keynote.
- diskcat 11y agoprogram is kinda hard to say because of the 2 r's.
- mikeash 11y agoYou're decades late on this. "App" has been used as a shorthand way to refer to programs for a loooong time. Random example, Apple had an object oriented framework called MacApp in 1985.
- digi_owl 11y agoBut outside of the Apple world program was most commonly used. It took the rise of the iPhone for app to displace program.
- hydromet 11y agoThis makes sense. The tight knit NeXT community used the "app" meme regularly staring at least in 1990 if not sooner.
- khedoros 11y agoTo me, "app" was just short for "application", and it usually implied something more than a program. A program was more of an individual binary and its data files. An application could be a suite of programs; basically, it was a superset of "program" that could include multiple binaries acting toward a common purpose. An "App" (mobile-style) is a new word. It implies (again, to me) a sandboxed program with a simplified, single-window, full-screen UI. The same 3 letters (app) have been used my entire life to refer to computer programs, but the connotation has shifted a lot.
- mikeash 11y agoIt seems pretty constant to me. It has always meant a user-facing program that's largely self-contained. It's not synonymous with "program," but since this story is about converting stuff for the Windows Store, I think it's being used correctly here.
- nothrabannosir 11y agoWhitelisting permissions instead of blacklisting them, hopefully. As far as I know, that is the main difference: apps are sandboxed programs which you can easily install and deinstall without affecting the rest of the system. Or...?
- notatoad 11y agoIn my mind an app is a sandboxed, focused thing that lives in a single window and behind a single launcher icon. application or program or any other older term from before iOS introduced "apps" could be a collection of a half-dozen different entries in your start menu, or an application like GIMP that scatters a bunch of different windows around your screen. "App" implies a level of simplicity.
- bradford 11y ago(disclaimer, I'm a Microsoft employee and this is only my opinion). There's an important distinction which often don't see discussed when this topic comes up: It can be very dangerous to install a program on your machine, but an 'app' comes with some assurance. People often think of the app store as a method for MS to grab your money, but in my opinion it fixes many of the installation/deployment problems that have existed on windows since... 95? 'Programs' typically require an MSI for installation. You'd better know, and trust, the MSI before you give it the required administrative privileges it needs to run, because a rogue MSI can absolutely own your machine. On the other hand, 'Apps' declare what they are going to do to your machine via the manifest, so you kind of know what you are getting into before your install. The apps are sandboxed, so they have limited ability to tamper with your machine, and they can be uninstalled in a more uniform fashion. In short, I feel much better telling my Grandma that she can install an 'App', but i'm much less confident telling her that it's ok to install a program via Installer.MSI.
- bradleyjg 11y agoThis sounds nice and reasonable, but I think it's a post hoc explanation that doesn't quite work. Look at the language in the linked article. It talks about converting my "Win32 apps" into "Universal Windows Platform apps". But those legacy programs aren't "apps" within the meaning you've laid out.
- bradford 11y agoI'll confess ignorance over what exactly the converter does, or how it does it. I don't know anything more than what was announced today. The article says that it converts win32/.net apps into appx packages, and I'd assume that this does encompass 'the meaning that I've laid out'.
- tstrimple 11y agoIt does. It sandboxes the filesystem and registry as well.
- Eyas 11y ago
- ioab 11y agoA couple of days ago, I was thinking how rare we use program word now. web apps, mobile apps, standalone apps...
- doener 11y agoIn Germany by the way "app" almost always means "mobile app", while desktop apps are still being called "Programme" aka programs in English.
- stuaxo 11y agoFairly sure it is just short for application. They used to be called apps when we made them for J2ME phones. Symbian apps were not sandboxed, but J2ME ones were, and this was the majority. Later on apple brought sandboxed apps to the iphone. And no-one knew what an app was back then, most seemed surprised that a person even made the games they played on their phones.
- 0x0 11y agoIt's weird to hear "win32" called "legacy". Last I checked everything from "wininit.exe" to "svchost.exe" to "winlogon.exe" were win32 (or win64) applications. Guess the entire base operating system is legacy! :O
- Aleman360 11y agoActually, a lot of what you see in Windows 10 is running on top of UWP.
- 0x0 11y agoSome of the UI apps perhaps, but if you ripped out win32, I don't think you'd have a very usable machine left to log on to?
- KirinDave 11y agoThat's true, but only because there isn't a great story in UWP for underlying services. Non-sandboxed applications and services are not a sustainable strategy anymore.
- maxxxxx 11y agoI wonder how long they'll stick to UWP. In 2 years they probably have another cool next thing.
- gh-lfneu28 11y agoYeah, they dropped that .net thing in less than that .. oh wait
- maxxxxx 11y agoThey have abandoned WPF, Winforms and Silverlight. Not sure what happened to WinRT.
- mtgx 11y agoUnless I heard it wrong, the title may be a little inaccurate. I believe they said "to the Windows store or any other store". So you may be able to put UWP apps on other web stores, too.
- analognoise 11y agoI wish Reactos was a valid replacement. I just want win32 without MS, they can keep the other garbage.
- mwcampbell 11y agoSo can we actually start using this yet? I hope it isn't still vapor.
- seanalltogether 11y agoHow does this work with the sandboxing requirements. Last time I tried to build an app for the ms store i hit an immediate wall with sandboxing and stopped proceeding with the idea. Are things more lax now?
- ridiculous_fish 11y agoLet's say I'm building something like an IDE, where I'm not targeting Xbox or phones. Is UWP appropriate for me? Should I aim to be on the Windows Store?
- bitwize 11y agoIt depends on the IDE; in particular, whether it competes with Microsoft's own line of business. Microsoft has historically had non-compete clauses in its dev tool EULAs. It was an EULA violation, for instance, to use Visual Studio to write a word processor, database, or spreadsheet program. I don't know if it still holds for the cuddly "new" Microsoft... but tread carefully. Windows Store is curated and thus more restrictive than straight Win32 app development would be.
- thebigshane 11y agoWait... what? Do you have a source for that? I can't find anything in my searches to confirm that. I did see various EULAs saying you can't redistribute some bits included with some of the MSDN products (like MSDN documentation and sample Jet DB files) with your product, if your product is primarily a general word processor, database, or spreadsheet application. But nothing like you can't write one of those applications at all.
- m_fayer 11y agoWith this tool I don't see why you wouldn't want to be on the Windows Store, if you can deal with the sandbox. UWP is another story. With UWP, you have to deal with the mobile-like app lifecycle of getting randomly suspended and/or shut down. This is a hassle to deal with but understandable on a mobile device. For something as heavy, complex, and background-processing intensive as an IDE, it doesn't make sense to me.
- pierrebai 11y agoI wish there would be more details. It reminds me of the very old Carbon Dater from Apple which used to tell you if your MacOS9 program ws compatible with Carbon on MacOSX and tell you exactly which OS function were gone, which were deprecated and what the alternatives for them were. Is Centennial the same approach? Or is it a wrapper around your app, taking your straight executable and just failing OS calls that are not supported and forbidden?