3 ms·
According to the article, the vulnerability was already known by a third party, and all the FBI did was ask/pay that third party to use it on this phone. I don'
by mikeash 11y ago
According to the article, the vulnerability was already known by a third party, and all the FBI did was ask/pay that third party to use it on this phone. I don't see how that act alters the security of iPhones.
I agree that the FBI should inform Apple of the vulnerability they used. I just don't think that failing to do so makes iPhones less secure. Failing to do so leaves them as they are, and informing Apple would make iPhones more secure.
I don't see this as pedantic, because it's the difference between the FBI actively harming us and the FBI merely not helping us.
- wkandek 11y agoI do not believe the FBI can legally report the vulnerability. They did not find it, they do not "own" it. They have used a service to get to the phone's data. Even if they reverse engineered the exploit used, it would be a breach of contract to disclose the vulnerability.
- chc 11y agoI'm not sure what "ownership" is supposed to mean in this context. Legally speaking, how does one "own" a security vulnerability?