31 ms·
It's not working as intended for either party. They both come out looking bad. Apple looks bad because they claimed that if they produced this software for th
by mc32 11y ago
It's not working as intended for either party. They both come out looking bad.
Apple looks bad because they claimed that if they produced this software for the FBI it would eventually get in the hands of international criminals and put their users at risk (this before the FBI tried compelling them so it would not have set court precedent). So the FBI did an about run and got someone to come up with a method to achieve the same aim, and so the end result to Apple users is the same, except Apple are in the dark as to what the vuln is. That's a position they'd like to not be in.
On the other hand, the FBI coming in and trying to compel Apple, after an initial rebuff, looks like it was unnecessary and makes them look less competent.
Now, given it took a third party to do this, the FBI can't very well disclose the third party's trade secret.
Lose-lose for both.
This should be titled "The iPhone was never as secure as we wanted to think it was"