5 ms·
Interoperability and the W3C: Defending the Future from the Present
- askyourmother 11y agoI've said it before, and I am sure it will be as unpopular now as then: there are people here who should know better, who can see where this road leads, but they are selfish "I know DRM is bad, but I got ta have ma Netflix!". Bad things happen because selfish people want to be spoon-fed digital junk food, and they will accept perverting the open web to achieve it. At the point the W3C accepted eme/DRM, it was already finished as a standards org, it just didn't realise it yet.
- irae 11y agoI don't see an issue, I don't watch netflix on my browser anymore. IMHO we can live without EME and we can get Netflix proprietary apps natively doing whatever they want to decode DRM on their own. We don't need to break the web for that.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mark_l_watson 11y agoI have really mixed feelings about this. On one hand, I enjoy renting new material from Google Plus Movies and TV, enjoy Hulu and Netflix. I understand the need for some form of DRM. On the other hand, I support the FSF and like to see open source options. For me, the best middle road is to isolate all of the DRM in one closed source web browsers, and have the rest of my system as close to liver software as is practical.
- julie1 11y agohuhu Whatever the DRM technique you have can always put in a low noise chamber a cam/microphone to make a close to the original reproduction by analogic means you can re-publish. People used to enjoy watching videos in 1024x768x16bpp and hearing is satisfied with 46KHz More than what can be achieved in AAD, or ADD chains. DRM is a chimera. It costs money and IP laws are flawed at the contractual level. Since Louis XIV when _lettre de Patentes_ where invented the deal was exclusivity granted to invest in new content versus free public domain when exclusivity disappears. Disney/Sony music are recycling public domain in so called original works (Grimm tales, 1900 pop songs converted in Rap melodies ...) hence breaking the deal. And exclusivity is getting WAY overboard. As if chosen authors where the new nobility of culture, while street art is being stolen by galleries and real artists lives in misery. Plus, except Gutenberg close to none public domain contents are cheaper than new one, while paying the artists are said to be the greatest expense. Try to find the integral of Shakespeare, Molière, The 1001 night tales for a decent price.
- fixermark 11y agoEssentially, the choices are not "Standardize DRM descriptions in the w3c process or don't have browsers supporting DRM at the HTML-model level." The choices are "Standardize DRM descriptions in the w3c process or have an ad-hoc collection of binary blobs, de-facto standards implemented by the dominant browser vendors, and external mobile players." If the w3c doesn't standardize the DRM descriptions, it just pushes the standards a little bit towards irrelevance as the industry interprets silence as damage and routes around it (especially given the current ecosystem where ever-more "web content" is actually vended through mobile apps). This may very well be the principled stand that the w3c should take---it may be correct to curtail themselves to only standardizing things that can be openly implemented. But we should observe that their lack of a hat in this ring isn't going to kill DRM-protected video streams---the owners of the content want that and are willing to pay a LOT of money to be lied to.
- nitrogen 11y agoLast time I checked, EME still results in an ad hoc collection of binary blobs. There's Google, Adobe, Microsoft, and Apple all with competing blobs.
- fixermark 11y agoIt results in a standard for describing them so that browsers can properly select the right one, or ignore all of them. That's less ad-hoc than the alternatives.
- nitrogen 11y agoBut it does very little, if anything, for the open web, and either needs total top to bottom specification for open implementation, or doesn't belong in a web standard.
- fixermark 11y agoThat may be true, but it is irrelevant. I don't know why you believe that the technologies under the W3C web standards need be open. The standards themselves need be open (they're published, after all), but the technologies underpinning them? Checking W3C's website, their guidelines for implementations appear to be "W3C issues a call for implementations as part of standardization and welcomes public participation" [https://www.w3.org/participate/implementation https://www.w3.org/participate/implementation]. Nothing in the formal standards process [https://www.w3.org/2005/10/Process-20051014/tr.html https://www.w3.org/2005/10/Process-20051014/tr.html] appears to require all implementations be "open," and that assumption flies in the face of previous legacy standards (<img> when .gif was an accepted file format but still encumbered by patent, the <object> and <embed> standards that specify closed-binary plugins to side-load). While it'd be nice if it worked the way you described, it seems that the standard as currently codified (including one specified "dummy" open reference implementation) is all that is needed.
- davexunit 11y agoDRM must not be allowed into a W3C Recommendation. The W3C has already lost staff over the issue, and stand to lose more if they ignore the thousands of people who object to this. I really hope that the protests and press from the FSF and EFF have helped steer the W3C into doing the right thing.
- feylikurds 11y agoWhen reading the beginning of the article, I did not get what the big deal was. It seemed to me that W3C just wanted to standardize existing DRM on the web and if you did not want to use DRM, then do not visit the site. But then I came to the part where developers can be sued under DMCA for trying to reverse-engineer the DRM (which inhibits new browsers, if they do not want to use proprietary binary blobs) and worst of all: It would be a return to the bad old days of websites that advised that they were "Best viewed with Netscape" or "Best viewed with Internet Explorer," because the new browsers would be locked out of some of their content.
- hyperion2010 11y agoOh man, I smell a court case pitting the ADA against the DMCA. I have this feeling ADA would win.
- wmf 11y agoThe Library of Congress is permitted to create exemptions from the DMCA and there are two for accessibility: http://itlaw.wikia.com/wiki/DMCA_Exemptions_to_the_Prohibition_on_Circumvention#Exemptions_granted_3 http://itlaw.wikia.com/wiki/DMCA_Exemptions_to_the_Prohibiti...
- dreamdu5t 11y agoWe don't need the W3C and never have.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]