4 ms·
> TL;DR: Companies don't hate "giving users more freedom" Software patents are an example of threatening user freedom, since users can be sued for using softwa
by cyphar 11y ago
> TL;DR: Companies don't hate "giving users more freedom"
Software patents are an example of threatening user freedom, since users can be sued for using software that has patented "ideas" in it.
> I've never met an IP lawyer working for a company with many (hundreds to thousands) of patents allow use of the GPLv3, out of fear that it could undermine their ability to enforce patent rights defensively.
The GPLv3 uses an almost-exact copy of the patent clause in the Apache 2 license (which is used by companies). The only difference is that it requires that the patent rights be transferred in a GPL-like way.
> Second, companies generally don't make it easy for users to run custom software on their products for a few reasons. You generally put software on products one of two ways: physically, or over-the-air (wifi/ethernet/some other way). With both methods, "signed" payloads are usually used for one of two reasons: to make sure it is error free.
All that is necessary is to provide some advanced option to add your own certificate. That's literally it. Once you have the source, you can figure out how to actually push the bloody thing (it'd be nice if a company provided whatever script they use, but they're probably not required to do it). This isn't a very complicated procedure, UEFI did it and that standard is basically owned by Microsoft.
- xyzzy_plugh 11y ago> All that is necessary is to provide some advanced option to add your own certificate. That's literally it. Once you have the source, you can figure out how to actually push the bloody thing (it'd be nice if a company provided whatever script they use, but they're probably not required to do it). This isn't a very complicated procedure Dude. I wish. I have seen things you wouldn't believe. Rube-Goldberg publishing mechanisms that couldn't be provided even if you tried. Not to mention getting QA resources to test it, someone to document it for the public, whatever engineering resources are necessary to allow it to be modified (what if it is in ROM?). You're talking millions of dollars of employee time, easy. And we were supposed to have shipped last month. I want to live in this world of yours too, but it is just not possible today.