8 ms·
Amazon bans the sale of rogue USB-C cables
- hollander 11y agoUSB-C is good news for consumers and companies alike because it helps standardize the very different kinds of ports and adaptors that tech firms have traditionally used for their products. But low quality and cheap cables have flooded the market, causing more harm than good by frying laptops and phones so that they can’t be used again. Finally, it seems that major distributors like Amazon are waking up to the issue and clamping down, but there’s plenty more to be done as Leung noted.
- cnvogel 11y agoOk, this is all nice and true, but how would such a thing be handled in practice? There's a difference between "Standards Compliant" and "Does not work for me". Many of the standards compliant cables might work just fine for a majority of users. Most specifically, the typical non-conformance was a wrong resistor value indicating that an A-to-C cable would be free to draw up to 3A from the A socket. This was in violation of maximum current allowed on an A connector, but I guess this is what many users appreciated, because it made the tablets charge faster. So, who gets to decide if a USB-C cable is nonconforming? Remember, we are not talking about expensive industrial or laboratory equipment but $10 (or ceaper) cables. Do I get to send it back to Amazon if it doesn't work with my USB-C device [which itself might be too picky, violating the standard] Or may I send it back when I can show a non-conformance using proper test equipment, even though the cable would work for most users? Does every vendor have to provide a certificate for successful passing of a testsuite/measurement? -- Also keep in mind that the specification doesn't only cover charge currents (which is pretty much exclusively what Benson Leungh had tested). And when I have demonstratively proven that a cable is dangerous, will Amazon reimburse all buyers?
- majewsky 11y ago> There's a difference between "Standards Compliant" and "Does not work for me". Many of the standards compliant cables might work just fine for a majority of users. I'd assume that a USB-Type C recepticle embedded in a costly device, such as a smartphone or notebook, is more likely to be manufactured by someone who adheres to the specs, or at least strives to.
- cnvogel 11y agoYes, I had assumed such things in the past, too... ;-). But of course you are right in general: A smartphone, notebook or tablet manufactured will likely be built to stricter standards than a random cable from a random Amazon seller. Nevertheless, "works with a good notebook" is generally not a replacement for a proper acceptance test. -- Typically it will be in favor of the marginally failing component, as standards always employ some safety margins, and properly built hardware will be forgiving for "slightly broken" cables. Such a cable may as well, and rightfully, fail with any number of other perfectly standards compliant computers.
- CPLX 11y agoAmazon has a genuine problem with their reputation brewing at this point. Here's an example: Try to buy replacement printer ink for a HP 8600 printer. This is a super common machine sold on special in Costco and Best Buy, possibly the most popular general purpose printer out there. Seriously, go to Amazon's site and try to just buy some replacement cartridges for it. The first result looks great, tons of reviews average almost five stars, appears to be sold by Amazon and made by HP: http://www.amazon.com/HP-Magenta-Original-Cartridges-CR314FN/dp/B005BZNE2A/ref=sr_1_1?s=office-products&ie=UTF8&qid=1459336766&sr=1-1&keywords=hp+951 http://www.amazon.com/HP-Magenta-Original-Cartridges-CR314FN... Now scroll down and look at the top customer reviews. Something is going on here. Are these real or refilled? Who exactly is selling them? OK go back to search results and look again. But there isn't any entry that stands out as obviously just made by HP and sold by Amazon, they all have similar problems. Ugh. This of course happened to me the other day. I spent 10 minutes trying to just figure out how to buy real OEM printer ink, gave up, and navigated over to HP.com where aside from typing in all my info again, it was painless and next day shipping was free. This has become a constant problem that Amazon has to fix. The next exercise for the reader is to try to find a pair of genuine Apple OEM headphones, the kind that come with the iPhone, that can be bought with actual confidence. That should be the easiest online shopping task imaginable, but it's literally impossible at this point on Amazon. Not slightly frustrating, impossible. And don't get me started on the switch to USPS shipping. Despite their seeming chokehold on online shopping, Amazon is vulnerable to competition that can solve these kinds of problems.
- nxzero 11y agoMy experience is that quality wise that OEM or "real" products offer better quality, but the risk in general doesn't negate the extra expense of buying the real thing; short-term this is, the half-life of non-real products is unpredictable and given the life spans of USB cords it's increasely worth the risk. Real issue is that complaint cables are over priced, and there no cheap way to confirm if a cord is non-complaint or for the matter if a device is complaint.
- DiabloD3 11y agoGenerally, if the cable isn't made by Anker, Monoprice, or AmazonBasics, why are you buying it?
- fluxquanta 11y agoTo your average consumer those names mean nothing (except for maybe AmazonBasics, because "Amazon" is in there).
- agumonkey 11y agoQuestion, is amazonbasics amazon.com or just a name trick that amazon.com allows ?
- hga 11y agoIt is Amazon.com, and generally of high or at least good enough quality, but you have to check the reviews. Given that they have their logo on the items, they'd better be careful about policing it.
- agumonkey 11y agoRight, the logo matches too. So far it seems like a curated list of cheap enough parts. No expectations of awesomeness just functional without hidden strings.
- DiabloD3 11y agoThey're Amazon.com's in house brand. They also do stuff that isn't electronics.
- throwaway049 11y agoI agree. I've bought cheap stuff that was dead on arrival and because it's so cheap, returning it for a refund wasn't worth the effort. Sad to think that this may be the core of someones business model, if only because that's some raw material that could have been manufactured into decent kit.