4 ms·
Which is why I find Linus's childish view of the GPL so frustrating. He claims to have never used it for "user freedom" reasons (even though I'm sure that's how
by cyphar 11y ago
Which is why I find Linus's childish view of the GPL so frustrating. He claims to have never used it for "user freedom" reasons (even though I'm sure that's how Richard Stallman would've persuaded him). If you frame the question of "is tivoisation bad" as "how could a psychopath use my code to harm users" it becomes clear that tivoisation is something we must reject.
- pksadiq 11y agoIts a fact that Linus doesn't even care about open source[0]. Then how will he be caring about software freedom? Hope, someday, we shall have GNU Hurd ready. Anyway, GNU guix is getting better. [0] http://www.techrepublic.com/article/linux-creator-linus-torvalds-doesnt-really-care-about-open-source/ http://www.techrepublic.com/article/linux-creator-linus-torv...
- lolidaisuki 11y agoHe used to care, sadly doesn't anymore.
- tdsamardzhiev 11y agoIndeed. He simply uses it because it's the best software development model. I think open source could use more people like him, though. P.S. Man, how I love downvotes without any arguments whatsoever.
- cyphar 11y agoI didn't down-vote you, but I'll explain why I don't like his view on free software. Free software is chiefly concerned with user freedom, to ethically treat users of your software. The GPL is the standard example of a free software license, and its purpose is to in perpetuity make sure that all users of your original code will always be able to use it in freedom. You may notice I didn't reference a "development model". In my opinion, development models are secondary to ethical issues such as user freedom. Yes, it turns out that the "bazaar" model of software development works pretty well, but that doesn't mean that you couldn't have a "cathedral" free software project. The problem with the "open source" movement is that there is no question about morals and ethics. It's just "here are 10 criteria which will give you good code, but if you find a better way to get good code, more power to you". It's plainly obvious when it comes to issues like vendor lock-in why "open source" doesn't have enough of a moral backing to explain why vendor lock-in is unacceptable. If the code is good quality, why are you complaining about vendor lock-in? I wish we had more people like Stallman who will bring attention to the important issue here, the issue of user freedom. Proprietary software hasn't been vanquished yet, and it's not going without a fight.
- cyphar 11y agoI just read that article and it's slightly depressing: > Between the launching of Linux and today, we've waded through decades of free and open source holy wars, but Torvalds' first instinct was right: Software doesn't want to be free, necessarily. It just wants to be open enough that developers can get to work with a minimum of fuss. sigh No, some of us do care about user freedom and are seriously worried about the recent attacks on user freedom done by companies like Amazon.
- ashitlerferad 11y agoAt least some of the Linux developers care about software freedom: https://sfconservancy.org/linux-compliance/ https://sfconservancy.org/linux-compliance/ https://sfconservancy.org/supporter/ https://sfconservancy.org/supporter/
- cyphar 11y agoYay! Downvotes without any justification!
- ars 11y agoThere is plenty of justification. > Which is why I find Linus's childish view This alone is enough. Someone has an opinion different than yours so you call them names? Then you have this: > If you frame the question of "is tivoisation bad" as "how could a psychopath use my code to harm users" it becomes clear that tivoisation is something we must reject. Which barely makes any sense. You could change it to "are oranges bad" as "how could a psychopath use an orange to harm users", for basically equivalent logic. Plus it appears to make the argument the tivoisation is GOOD since it stops the psychopath. It's basically nonsense framed as insight. You deserved your downvotes - and I don't downvote lightly.
- cyphar 11y agoTivoisation is bad because the corporation that uses it is the psychopath. Wasn't that obvious from context? As for oranges, since we don't create oranges and there's nothing that you can do that's immoral with an orange that isn't also illegal. There are things you can do with software which are legal but are immoral. As for Linus having a childish view: how else do you describe a simplified view like "the GPL is basically where I get people to give their changes back to me -- that's it"? That's emphatically not the only thing that the GPL is for (regardless of whether or not you agree with the ethics).