3 ms·
I have a VERY deep problem with this that has nothing to do with the views of anybody involved. The problem I have is that this is a mob turning its power on s
by bsder 11y ago
I have a VERY deep problem with this that has nothing to do with the views of anybody involved.
The problem I have is that this is a mob turning its power on someone with FAR LESS power than the mob in question. It is one thing when the mob attacks someone of greater power as greater power can defend itself. It is something else when a mob expresses itself with positive support for the downtrodden--that's still okay. However, attacking someone unable to match with equal social defense is NOT okay. We have a word for that--it's called "bullying".
The people involved may feel righteous, but that doesn't change the fact that they are bullies. And, I am disappointed that a conference of geeks can't seem to identify social bullying when it occurs in front of them.
As always, people only seem to be able to empathize when they are on the receiving end of the pointy stick.
- mcphage 11y ago> this is a mob turning its power on someone with FAR LESS power than the mob in question Most of the discussions and conversation about power deal with 1-on-1 situations: person X has more power than person Y, for reasons A, B, and C. But group action—that's a different matter, and I don't know how it figures into the picture. Person X may have more power than P, Q, R, S, or T—but P, Q, R, S, and T together may have more power than X. Or they may not. When and how they do is an important question, that I wish we had better answers to.
- bsder 11y ago> but P, Q, R, S, and T together may have more power than X. Or they may not. When and how they do is an important question, that I wish we had better answers to. There are rarely clean answers when the problem is social. In this instance, however, it is very clear that the mob has far more power than the individual they are targeting. For the person in question, if he had equivalent power, he could simply replace the sponsors and lost speakers with people who shared his views. At that point, the mob would be VERY reluctant to pull out for fear of leaving the stage to people whom they find distasteful. The fact that this mob would have a very different behavior if he actually had real power is telling and disappointing.
- pron 11y agoI am not sure you're analyzing the power structure correctly. The organizers of the conference had never been subjects to marginalization and harassment prior to the incident; they're only subjects to protest now. The people making the protests -- minorities in tech -- have been subject to constant harassment and marginalization, both before the incident and during the incident, and they will be subject to marginalization long after. It's like you're complaining about a small army that attacks a much larger one at a point where its defenses are relatively weak. That's good tactics; not unfairness. Women got the vote, and racial segregation was reduced using the exact same means that you call bullying. Protest is a very effective tool of social change, and in order for it to work it needs to protest things it has a chance of winning. Like a small army, it can only do so by concentrating power on one target at a time. That's just the only viable strategy for the weaker side.
- eru 11y agoAre you sure the protests are done by any actual minorities, not in the `name of' said minorities?