2 ms·
At the risk you of you never seeing this ... Put your email in your profile! The thing about ideas is that you can't really test how they will perform in the
by apsurd 17y ago
At the risk you of you never seeing this ...
Put your email in your profile!
The thing about ideas is that you can't really test how they will perform in the reality because they are not _real_. For example as a programmer I have tons of ideas about how to execute a given task. In my head it's very easy (and fun) to see my implementation play out. But it's only when you actually start to make the idea real that unforseen problems come into existence - this is a good thing, it's iteration. But without making the idea tangible, I would argue you cannot realistically measure an idea right?
Put another way ideas can only be iterated in your mind. That's great if you are a philosopher (hey you should really be a philosopher). But I think most things that yield empirical data need to exist in reality and therefore you need execution.
This is of course taking nothing away from philosophy. Maybe that's what you've been looking for? Or perhaps a futurist or something. You can "sell ideas" via books right? But then again writing a book is creating something tangible =)
--
Reading some of your other responses I can see that you take idea iteration quite seriously. This very well puts you leagues above guys that want to "make twitter better" or what not. But I think you need to accept that idea guys are more akin to starving artists. You should create ideas because you love to create ideas, not because you want to monetize them (that's what action is for). This also analogs nicely with philosophers, and other academics. They have to risk "some other guy" ultimately getting credit for work they've also explored. Also academics don't _necessarily_ get paid to "think", they get paid to _teach_ and think.
- nekopa 17y agoThanks for adding your input to this thread. I think that the way I am eventually going to go is the "starving artist" route. I do love creating ideas, but I hope "some other guy" can monetize them via action. I think I will just have to face the fact that like other people here (I've seen a number of threads on the topic) I will have to do some triage, filter out my best idea for execution, do it, make money, then maybe return to this problem. I think people are willing to pay for ideas (or even a book) from someone who has proved that at least one of their ideas has had value. Well off to finish creating my "Customer Evolution System" a piece of software that is a hybrid of the Customer Development process monitoring and a CRM I hope I can get a beta version done by the end of March and have some people here try it out, as it is especially designed with startups in mind. Then maybe pg will overlook the single founder problem and I can enter it into the next YC. Thanks everyone on here for their time, and btw, I have added my email into my profile if anyone else has any more comments.