3 ms·
This makes a lot of sense, but I see a few issues. One, you say 'risky long-term behavior'... so how do we define something as being risky? If I am a corporati
by cortesoft 11y ago
This makes a lot of sense, but I see a few issues.
One, you say 'risky long-term behavior'... so how do we define something as being risky? If I am a corporation who wants to take risky long term behavior, why wouldn't I just hide the risk? If the bad thing happens, oh well, they have limited liability... if the bad thing doesn't happen, sweet we got to take the risk and not pay for insurance!
If we say every corporation needs insurance, and that insurance company is supposed to take unlimited liability for the corporation that they are insuring, then this insurance is going to be CRAZY expensive. The insurers are running huge risks, since the possible liability is infinite. If we say the the liability is capped at some number, then we are back to the same issue where the company taking the risky behavior is not liable for the full damage.
- btilly 11y agoI would say that deliberately hiding risks is grounds for piercing the corporate veil and making shareholders personally liable. :-) Obviously in practice there needs to be a cap. But the cap should be set high enough to cover the upper limit of the claims that reasonably could happen. Which means that the cap needs to be astronomically high. For example if you're potentially affecting the health of a town, you should be able to compensate them for their actual losses. Including the cost of supporting sick people on disability for the rest of their lives. Like it or not that is the actual potential liability of your action. You shouldn't have to pay anything like that up front. But if 1% of fracking wells leak, and 1% of those leaks get into a town's water supply, then yes, you may have to be ready to compensate dozens of people for the cost of medical care and years of disability.