4 ms·
This war on math is still bullshit
- jhbadger 11y agoThe problem with saying that the whole thing is bullshit because encryption is just math is that it ignores that laws really would prevent companies from putting encryption (useful forms of it anyway) on phones. Yes, elite hackers (and perhaps terrorists, but they are not usually very bright people) could encrypt their phones anyway, but the vast majority of non-technological people wouldn't if it was difficult and/or involved breaking laws.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoSaying that cryptography restrictions are a war on math is like saying explosive restrictions are a war on physics. It's ignorant. What we're really talking about is if a man-made construct should be free, regulated, banned, or some combination depending on context. We're then talking cost-benefit analysis of that. Then, my side argues against such restrictions given they imply huge, potential costs with virtually no benefits to the public. Much more reasonable.
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoCall me biased, but that analogy doesn't work. Explosives aren't made from physics. An understanding of the physics involved is insufficient to manufacture them. They aren't just a man-made construct, they tangible objects. You can't will an atomic bomb into existence by drawing up plans for one. Cryptographic functions, on the other hand, are pure math. The concept and the implementation are one and the same. They are nothing but a mental construct built from basic mathematical principles. If even one human understands cryptography and shares that knowledge, nothing can stop the whole planet from using it. So, is there a war on math? If there is a war on cryptography (I don't think there is any more, we won that war years ago), then yes, there is a war on mathematics.
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"Explosives aren't made from physics. An understanding of the physics involved is insufficient to manufacture them. They aren't just a man-made construct, they tangible objects." "Cryptographic functions, on the other hand, are pure math." Oh, wow, you're living up to your name in this one. The bomb works through physics. The crypto works through math. The purpose and result come through a specific configuration. And, no, cryptographic functions are not "pure math:" they're instruction sequences trying to implement math on computers powered by the physics of electrical engineering. Next you'll be telling me side channels don't exist because they're not in the math. "Don't Trust the Math" https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/10/friday_squid_bl_396.html#c2056522 https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2013/10/friday_squid_...
- pixl97 11y ago>The bomb works through physics So I can take a box of physics and make a bomb? No. Bombs require chemicals and they can be regulated. >The crypto works through math. Yes, as in you don't need the computer hardware to actually do the encryption. You could do it on paper if you wanted (and had an unlimited amount of time). The encryption is agnostic of the actual hardware it runs on.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoSo, I can take some math equations and I have working SSL deployment? No, they require machine instructions on electrical equipment. Both can be regulated. And your model requires user to have unlimited amoumt of time? I dont know many crypto deploymemts supporting that. Your model gets even further from reality.
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoYou can't regulate machine instructions, dude. Are you gonna build a computer that can run any sequence of instructions except the ones that implement a cryptographic algorithm?
- mobiuscog 11y agoThis whole 'war' is actually about convenience and nothing to do with privacy (or 'math'). If you want your information to be private, don't store it on a device that cannot guarantee that privacy. If you have to use that device, encrypt the data first, yourself. Oh, but wait, that takes time and is hassle - I like the device manufacturer / network provider / etc. to do that for me so I DON'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT MY PRIVACY. If it's that important to you, ensure it happens. If it's too inconvenient, it's obviously not really that important. Of course, that's what 'smart' phones are in the first place - money & privacy in exchange for convenience. shrug
- cmdrfred 11y agoWhat happens when crypto is banned and the 'terrorists' have a copy of openPGP.js or sjcl.js saved somewhere?