3 ms·
And in a world with deflation, putting money under the mattress is actually a good investment strategy. The resulting deflationary spiral is self-reinforcing.
by btilly 11y ago
And in a world with deflation, putting money under the mattress is actually a good investment strategy.
The resulting deflationary spiral is self-reinforcing. Fear of this state is why central banks try to create a consistent level of inflation.
- mindslight 11y agoAnd yet the bona fide purpose of economic competition is to always be lowering prices through optimization, the technology sector being the strongest (most meta) example of this. If the deflation doom sayers were as prescient as they purport, we'd all still be using 386s waiting for Intel to announce they've created the fastest chip they will ever be able to. In fact, the system is bistable. Inflation has the same self-reinforcing spiral, and we're living it! The moneyprinters' metric (CPI) has become the goal unto itself - anything technological keeps getting ever-cheaper, so anything that can be financialized (the quickest feedback path where printed money returns to the CPI) shoots through the roof.
- btilly 11y agoI have no idea where you're getting your opinion about "deflation doom sayers" from. But you're right that the system has some bistability. A deflationary spiral with declining production and lifestyle can sustain itself for a long time. It is also sustainable to maintain a moderate inflationary spiral with ever increasing production and improving lifestyle. Given that choice, isn't it obvious why bankers try to keep the latter option going? But it is not actually bistable. Keeping moderate inflation going requires continual intervention. It is easy to fall off the rails into a hyper-inflationary disaster. It is easy to fall off the rails the other way into a deflationary disaster. And continued success creates the moral hazard of overconfidence in the stability of the system. This overconfidence leads to risky behavior which in the end WILL result in disaster. We came close to that in 2008. It is unclear to me whether it is better to have regular smaller disasters, or occasional large ones. But pushing off the next disaster is always better in the short run.
- mindslight 11y agoThe classic story about the deflation bogeyman is that if prices will be lower tomorrow, people won't buy things today. This is demonstrably false with regards to technology purchases, and obviously false with regards to necessities like food. People may delay purchases, but this is a good thing if say you're concerned about resource depletion or general efficiency. I'd say we're in the making of a hyper-inflationary disaster, as central banks continue to apply their top-down prescription of "productivity", forcing people to work full time make-work jobs (eg FIRE) rather than letting the majority slowly build up savings and create economic conditions that naturally lead to working less (as one would expect from uh, technological progress). The message just won't be received until the petrodollar has completely disintegrated though.
- btilly 11y agoThe deflationary spiral only starts to set in when the increase in wealth due to deflation competes with the potential increase in wealth from trying to use capital productively. So it isn't necessarily a problem if you can wait a year and then buy a better computer with the same money. But it IS a problem if your best investment strategy for that year would have been to put the money under the mattress instead of loaning it out, investing in stocks, or some other activity that keeps money circulating. As for a hyper-inflationary disaster, the exact monetary injection you use to stave off deflation can also create inflation. This is why central banks have such a challenge on their hands. They are trying to balance the economy between nasty extremes, while trying to satisfy contradictory goals.
- javajosh 11y agoCan you contact me? I have some questions about your assertions I'd like to take offline, particularly about your "petrodollar" comment below.