2 ms·
> The entire discussion was about how good Carlyle's work on slavery was. The entire subject matter is a defense of the use of slavery and in particular black p
by tzs 11y ago
> The entire discussion was about how good Carlyle's work on slavery was. The entire subject matter is a defense of the use of slavery and in particular black people as slaves. Which he was defending and promoting, as he then directly said slavery was a natural human relationship.
OK...so now it sounds like I need to read the entire wall of text to get the point? That illustrates a big difference between how you responded to me and how tptacek responded to me.
After I said that I saw the AMA, and that Yarvin's discussion of suitability of various groups to slavery did not seem to indicate he called for enslaving black people, your answer was to cite a couple of his blogs posts, and mention very specific parts of those posts.
I went and read those specific parts of those posts, not the whole posts. I found that those parts did not support your argument.
tptacek, on the other hand, told me that he could provide a citation for the claim, but that it would be complicated because Yarvin is an obscurantist. The impression I get from this and other comments of tptacek is that individual parts of Yarvin's writings have reasonable non-racists explanations (deliberately) so you have to look at the whole giant walls of text.
tptacek has an excellent record of backing up claims with complete and accurate cites when requested, and from this and other comments he's made on the matter the impression I get is that if I were to ask for the details I'd end up with a big list of long articles that I'd have to read in their entirety to get the point. I don't want to read a bunch of giant walls of text on this subject, and it sounds like it would be a lot of work for him to produce it, so I didn't ask for it.
> Maybe you should ask the other person in this thread who you trust implicitly if I'm wrong about this.
I'm not saying you are wrong on this...I'm saying you've failed to show that you are right. I accepted tptacek's response not because of any implicit trust, but rather because he offered a good explanation for why he was not providing a list of citations unless I really wanted them.
If you had said something like "Yarvin can write reasonable justifications for individual points, like he did in the AMA, but when you look at the writing as a whole a different picture emerges" and then linked to a few of his posts, we wouldn't be having this conversation, because as with tptacek I'd have decided I was not interested in going that deep.
- tptacek 11y agoTo be clear: I think you can get a pretty good bead on where Yarvin is coming from just from his writing (you have to read it diligently though, and I agree it's not worth the trouble). But there are also very troubling eyewitness reports about things he's said in person that provide a pretty convenient shortcut to doing that.