4 ms·
A patent for a physical invention lays out, in its claims, precisely how an invention works. A lever-arm here, a catch there Only if it was written by a really
by HeyLaughingBoy 17y ago
A patent for a physical invention lays out, in its claims, precisely how an invention works. A lever-arm here, a catch there
Only if it was written by a really crappy lawyer! The company I work for spent months coming up with a design for a mechanism and ended up with something pretty suboptimal in order to avoid all the existing patent claims. A good patent attorney will state the claims as generally as possible. e.g., don't call out a "10-24 screw," instead call out a "fixed or removable fastener" or "a means of locating the rotating element" etc. You may be confused because many patents show drawings, but those drawings are only examples to illustrate the concept, not necessarily actual claims
- fnid2 17y agoSounds like innovation to join a market, rather than innovation to create a market. Why not just patent an improvement on an existing product? That's one good thing about open source software. Improvements can just be tacked on. You don't have to go invent something totally new. That is one thing that separates software and machines. It's hard to tack a more efficient engine onto a 5 year old tractor.
- roc 17y agoYou're arguing one simplified example while having ignored the thrust of the argument. Yes, applications on physical inventions try to broaden their claims as much as possible. But there is still a substantial and quantitative difference between the domain covered by "fixed or removable fastener" and "a network" or "a process".