4 ms·
A complete list of things caused by global warming
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI've been meaning to blog about this for some time -- AGCC has reached the point where it is included in just about any other piece of research, no matter how tangential -- but haven't had the time. This site just throws the data out there for your perusal. Cato the Elder had the habit, no matter what the topic, to include the phrase in his speeches "And Carthage must be destroyed" -- Carthago delenda est No matter what came up, he always added "Carthago delenda est" The farmers have had a good harvest this year, and Carthage must be destroyed. I am very happy to receive this honor, and Carthage must be destroyed. Nice toga you're wearing, and Carthage must be destroyed. I think this list stands on it's own. No matter what the topic, climate change is presented as a big factor. It's become the universal plug-and-play prime mover. This is especially interesting in the context of no statistically significant global warming in the last decade or two. Of course, all generalizations are false, change doesn't necessarily mean warming, micro-climate is not the same as macro-climate, etc, etc. But you get the point. If the list isn't enough to make the rhetorical point well, perhaps somebody with more time than I have can write it up in a good essay. I know I'd like to read it. Link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carthago_delenda_est http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carthago_delenda_est
- thaumaturgy 17y ago"There might be dramatic changes in our global climate in the future." "Pfft. Crazy talk. The Earth has always been exactly as it is now." "We might be contributing to these changes because of our polluting ways." "No we aren't. It's too big. There's no way that 6 billion people could have any effect on the Earth's climate." "We think we have some evidence. Look..." "HAH! Look, here, see? Your numbers don't all match! You're a fraud! You just want money to continue your prestigious work!" "Uhm ... sure. But look, the climate affects a lot of things, y'know." "Yeah, so?" "So, here's a partial list of things which might be affected by climate." "LOLOL! There's no way one thing could be blamed for all of these! No way! That just proves you're a crock!" ...But, uhm, hey, thanks for contributing to the debate, or something.
- miked 17y ago"Pfft. Crazy talk. The Earth has always been exactly as it is now." One of the main claims of climate skeptics like myself is that the earth has always been changing, and that temperature changes seen recently are largely a result of these natural (mostly solar) cycles. This would explain why Mars was also heating up for a while. You need to get another set of straw men.
- maweaver 17y agoMy favorite example of this is Katrina. It wasn't a hugely powerful storm like say Andrew (it was only a Category 3 at landfall), it just happened to hit at exactly the wrong spot. People have been talking about this happening since before I was born, so it shouldn't have been a huge shock when it finally did. Despite this, and despite the fact that we have had a string of mild hurricane seasons since then, Katrina is often pointed to as an example of the kind of worse-than-usual storms we can expect in the future.
- ajross 17y agoUh... Katrina was a "worse-than-usual" storm, by pretty much every metric. Not the biggest (though the cat-3-at-landfall was because of a luckily-timed eyewall cycle, it was absolutely a cat-5 storm), but certainly one of the most memorable. So what's wrong with using a memorable storm as an example of similar storms?
- fleitz 17y agoNothing is wrong with it except that most of the damage was caused by the genius idea of building below sea/water level in an area known to be inundated with hurricanes which tend to cause increases in sea level and then neglecting to maintain the levies to keep the water out. It surely wasn't individuals and various levels gov't making cataclysmically bad decisions, no sirree, it was global warming. Also, the gov't should have had more boats on hand for actors to rescue puppies.
- petewarden 17y agoNothing is wrong with it except that most of the damage was caused by the genius idea of adding gases to the atmosphere that basic physics tell us trap heat, in a world where people love to live in low-lying areas next to bodies of water, and then neglecting to worry about any curbs on this massive experiment in 'what happens next?'
- fleitz 17y ago
- mattmaroon 17y agoThis is valueless and trollish. It proves nothing other than that uninformed people who've made up their mind in the absence of logic exist on both sides of the debate, which you already knew.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoAs I said, I was pressed for time, but the first few links I clicked on all had "research", "study", "survey", or "report" in the body text. That's not just somebody's opinion. Usually with nouns like this there is funding and somebody somewhat professional behind it. But if it's just rampant speculation by uninformed people I apologize. I certainly didn't mean to spam the board. Care to prove your point that somehow all of these reports, surveys, studies, and findings are bogus? Or is this just a way not to deal with the overwhelming amount of research with unusual conclusions that somehow links into climate change? By the way, my guess is that this is a conservative list, created for impact. The actual list of suspicious links and conclusions is probably much more boring -- and much more extensive. This is just the tip of the iceberg. But I'm happy to be proven wrong.
- ErrantX 17y agoThe only thing to say there is that words like research and survey tend to be ten a penny; especially in areas like this. Additionally it's got to be so hard to filter out things that aren't just tengentially caused. I'm sure many of this links hold valuable info and insight. My only concern is that this isn't the correct way to combine it all: I might do some research and combine a paper if I get some spare time.
- mattmaroon 17y agoExactly. Most of what is called "research" is just an attempt to prove something someone already believed. They come up with a theory, set out to prove it, and toss out any data contrary to their theory unseen. This happens on both sides of any high-stakes debate. You'd have to be pretty naive to not know this. Even if every single thing on this list is bullshit, which much probably is, all it proves is that this issue has long since left the realm of actual scientific debate. People who support the theory think everyone who denies it is ignorant, but most supporters (of which I am one, vaguely) don't realize that their team is full of ignorance too. I suppose maybe it's useful to point that out, I just assume everyone here already knows this.
- lhorie 17y agoFrom the site's homepage: Welcome to Number Watch All about the scares, scams, junk, panics, and flummery cooked up by the media, politicians, bureaucrats, so-called scientists and others who try to confuse you with wrong numbers. Working to combat Math Hysteria. It basically looks like an extensive list of news articles about varied topics that make mention of global warming (it being the fad-du-jour in journalism and all)
- Zarkonnen 17y agoUm. You do realise that this is how science works? People come up with theories, and then they're discussed. Discussed, not used as a political cudgel. The people to blame aren't the scientists but the press who take "x may be related to y" and turn it into "X CAUSES Y!".
- BearOfNH 17y agoSo for the past few years Al Gore has been just the leader of a discussion group. Odd, I don't recall him doing much listening.
- thaumaturgy 17y agoOne of my favorite takes on this: http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1174 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1174
- zb 17y agoIt seems to me that the media want stories about what global warming is affecting right now. Which is ridiculous, because the point is what might happen in the future and how quickly we can adapt if the rate of change is high. Unfortunately other people pick up on the fact that most of what the media report about bad things that have been caused by global warming is rubbish (true, as far as I can tell) and extrapolate this to "proof" that nothing bad will ever be caused by global warming (non sequitur).
- flabbergaster 17y agoNot complete: it's missing itself.
- realitygrill 17y agoI am actually really looking forward to reading Brignell's books. This particular page might only be an indicator of how out-of-control the global warming meme is, but I'm under the impression Brignell's stances are at least an approximation of how you should honestly approach the subject/studies. Who's read him? (I actually think I was linked to numberwatch on HN)