6 ms·
“We’d like to go home to our families, but the Sherpas are worried that if we cancel the expedition we will not get paid. We are willing to continue.” Capitali
by collyw 11y ago
“We’d like to go home to our families, but the Sherpas are worried that if we cancel the expedition we will not get paid. We are willing to continue.”
Capitalism in its purest form.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AustinG08 11y agowut? seems more like an extreme form to me.
- jdmichal 11y agoGenuinely curious: What is "extreme" capitalism? How does it differ from "pure" capitalism, in this example?
- mfoy_ 11y agoIt depends, if you think 100% pure unadulterated capitalism is a good thing, then "pure" is "good". If you think capitalism needs some checks and bounds then "pure" is "bad". In the former case, "extreme capitalism" and "pure capitalism" may be two different things. In the latter, they are synonymous. Essentially... depends on your point of view.
- jdmichal 11y agoI still fail to see the difference. You seem to be suggesting that "extreme" is being used as a bad replacement for "against my moral views"? That is, that "pure" capitalism is "extreme" capitalism if and when "pure" capitalism is "bad"? What would qualify as "extreme" capitalism in the former?
- davnn 11y agoDid I really just read that discussion? Have to stop wasting time on HN.
- AustinG08 11y agoIn this example? I don't know, maybe this is what capitalism looks like in Nepal, but I've never been so I have no idea. All I know is my paycheck isn't drenched in blood, sweat, and tears, which to be clear, I am very grateful for.
- jdmichal 11y agoYou said it seems like an "extreme" form. Now you don't know what that means? I don't mean to seem confrontational; I simply didn't and still don't understand your comment. So far my guess is that, as hinted in this and another response [0], that "extreme" is being used as a euphemism for "things I morally disagree with". Which, to me, does not make it any less "pure", but is rather your judgement on what "pure" capitalism is. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11376801 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11376801
- AustinG08 11y agoWell capitalism is defined as: "an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state." I don't see how this tragic event is a pure form of anything except tragedy.
- jdmichal 11y agoA tragic event happened. The Sherpa valued going home to mourn, and also valued being paid. I believe that collyw was suggesting that in "pure" capitalism, payment wouldn't occur unless services are rendered. So the ideas of "going home to mourn" and "being paid" would be incompatible. The result as stated was that "being paid" was considered to be of higher value, and thus they would continue. This is capitalism, because the Sherpa were privately allocating their capital (in this case, themselves and their skills) to what they considered the most valuable pursuit at the moment. I don't make any value judgements in the above, except perhaps in the first sentence. It's simply my interpretation of the comment, and how the quote was representing "pure" capitalism in my understanding. I think by now you have sufficiently, if indirectly, answered my question of what you meant by "extreme". It seems like I was probably correct in my guess.
- omonra 11y agoImho it ultimately comes down to whether the clients will demand their money back. If they don't - I don't see why operators would even mind. But if they do - the operators will have to pay costs (permits, sherpas, etc) while having no revenue.
- takk309 11y agoMost people that climb Everest take out insurance that protects them from a cancellation of their trip. It is the insurance companies that, in turn, refuse payment to the Sherpa.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> Most people that climb Everest take out insurance that protects them from a cancellation of their trip. It is the insurance companies that, in turn, refuse payment to the Sherpa. That can't be the full story, though. Because the obvious answer to that is that the Sherpa mountaineers should purchase insurance against cancellation of bookings (this is quite common for tourist attractions in more developed economies). Underwriting this insurance would be quite easy, because the people who underwrite the insurance policies for the tourist climbers should be quite happy to underwrite policies for the Sherpa mountaineers as well.
- takk309 11y agoYou raise a very good point about the Sherpa needing to have insurance against a failed expedition. Sadly, they rarely even have life insurance. An article from Rock and Ice cites a death benefit of $4,600 in 2013.[1] [1] http://www.rockandice.com/lates-news/exploitation-everest-sherpas-no-longer-willing-to-grin-and-bear-it http://www.rockandice.com/lates-news/exploitation-everest-sh...
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThe GDP per capita in Nepal is $700. So $4,600 is 6.5 years of wages. That's like someone in the west who makes $100,000 a year having a $650,000 life insurance. Which is a whole hell of a lot more than the one my employer offers.
- zeveb 11y agoWere it not for capitalism, they'd be living in extreme poverty, scratching out a marginal existence on the borders of the world. Because of capitalism, they are far better off than they would be. Capitalism at its finest.
- shimon 11y agoAssuming the Sherpas aren't forced into this line of work, then you're right - they're choosing it over the alternatives because it's a better option for them. That doesn't mean that it's ethical for visitors to a country to enjoy a sport wherein they pay to transfer risk of death away from themselves and onto less advantaged local people. I'm not against this type of deal in principle - it's vital to the existence of institutions like EMS and the military - but when the whole thing exists so that megalomaniacs can tick off another box on the "hard things I've achieved" list, there is a real question of justice. Most people who love capitalism might still draw the line at some types of transactions -- maybe your line is at selling organs or child prostitution, but it probably exists somewhere.
- chc 11y ago> Assuming the Sherpas aren't forced into this line of work, then you're right - they're choosing it over the alternatives because it's a better option for them > That doesn't mean that it's ethical for visitors to a country to enjoy a sport wherein they pay to transfer risk of death away from themselves and onto less advantaged local people. I have trouble seeing how it's more ethical to remove the choice from their hands and force them to do things that they demonstrably would rather not do.
- shimon 11y agoThat's hardly the only alternative. A visitor could instead pay them to be a guide, even a mountaineering guide on another thrilling but less suicidal trek.
- civilian 11y agoDon't we often transfer risk of death while buying certain products? Doesn't my enjoyment of king crab rely on transferring the risk of death while fishing in the arctic from myself to poor fishermen in Alaska? Doesn't any diamond I buy rely on conflict or slavery?
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoWhy does your interpretation of capitalism not have agreements? Having clients sign on to cancellation/abort fees is fairly common. In other words: contracts, contracts, contracts. Slavery, mercantilism, barter system, communism, etc don't solve this problem any better. In fact, historically, they're much, much worse.
- simonh 11y agoCapitalism has nothing particularly to do with people getting paid for their labour. That occurs in lots of economic systems including communism, anarcho-syndicalism, etc. It's about who pays for the means of production, who owns the businesses and who is paying for the labour. But there is still labour and the labour has to be paid for and there needs to be some agreement about that under any economic system. There are plenty of articles on Wikipedia that can help explain this, if you're confused about it.
- maxander 11y agoOne might argue that in a communist or otherwise "leftist" system, conditions of payment would have more to do with a rational assessment of the situation, rather than as a trade. The sherpas being paid in spite of not having done the work they had contracted for, due to some mere unforeseen circumstances, being a good example of the former kind of reasoning. Whether a communist system actually would or could operate in this manner is probably best left as an empirical question.