3 ms·
> The $900 comes from trust. Trust of whom? Who prints the money?
by pdonis 11y ago
> The $900 comes from trust.
Trust of whom? Who prints the money?
- kbenson 11y agoI said "I could issue a number of these notes". It comes of trust in me, or trust in the system of people getting notes from me, as they see the outcomes. There is no difference in printing my own notes than the government printing theirs beyond the trust of the people that it's worth something. That's an intrinsic feature of fiat money. People can lose faith in government currency, there's numerous cases around the world of it happening before. We aren't trading actual physical goods (gold, silver) or notes directly exchangeable for them any more, and haven't been for a long while.
- pdonis 11y ago> I said "I could issue a number of these notes". Not in our current system. Only the government can issue notes; for anyone else to do so is illegal. That was my point. (It's true that, in our current system, most money creation is actually electronic--entries in accounting databases--rather than physical notes. But all of that money creation is still done under rules set down by the government, and denominated in the government's fiat currency. So it's equivalent, for my purposes here, to the government printing notes directly. And nobody can just decide to create, say, a new bank deposit any time they want, or denominate it in their own currency.) > There is no difference in printing my own notes than the government printing theirs beyond the trust of the people that it's worth something. In principle this is, of course, true. But I wasn't arguing that our current system is the only possible fiat money system with fractional reserve banking. I was only arguing that, in our current system as it exists, the government is in fact the only entity allowed to print money (with the qualifications I gave above).
- kbenson 11y agoOkay, then the answer to your question "Where does the rest of the money that's lent out come from?" is that it's a passed through loan. The central bank (government) lends the bank you are dealing with funds at a specific rate (publicized), in large amounts. The bank you are getting a loan from then re-lends this money to you at a higher rate. You could lend the money you borrowed yourself to your friends at an even higher rate, if you liked. You would need to make sure your friends were likely to pay you back though, as if they don't you would still be liable for the money you borrowed (thus why you charge a higher rate, in addition to trying to make some money). The government lends to banks and not you because it's easier to assess the risk, and different banks are more willing to take bets and invest in specific things the government might see as too risky.
- pdonis 11y ago> then the answer to your question "Where does the rest of the money that's lent out come from?" is that it's a passed through loan In other words, the original source of the rest of the money is the government. Yes, that is exactly the point I was trying to make. > You could lend the money you borrowed yourself to your friends at an even higher rate, if you liked. Yes, but unlike commercial banks, you can't have the government print extra money (directly or indirectly) just because you made a loan. Nor can you lend money to your friends and also give the same money back to whoever you got it from, without waiting for your friends to pay back the loan. > The government lends to banks and not you because it's easier to assess the risk I understand that that's the story we get told, but that doesn't make it true. The government lends to banks because it is transferring wealth to the banks, but doesn't want to make it obvious that that's what is happening.
- kbenson 11y ago> Yes, but unlike commercial banks, you can't have the government print extra money (directly or indirectly) just because you made a loan. Nor can you lend money to your friends and also give the same money back to whoever you got it from, without waiting for your friends to pay back the loan. Well, to a degree you can. There's probably always someone to lend to you at some rate. Future loans would have to use this new rate. That's not much different than Fed lending. You don't get to participate in a large system where the friction of that is all worn away, but that's a matter of scale. I don't think we are discussing the right of individuals to get all the benefits of working at scale. > I understand that that's the story we get told, but that doesn't make it true. The government lends to banks because it is transferring wealth to the banks, but doesn't want to make it obvious that that's what is happening. So the government is transferring wealth to the banks. That's indisputable. I don't agree that's the purpose of the arrangement though. It's a byproduct (but a byproduct a lot of people like, and try to make sure they perpetuate) of the real goal, which is economic advancement for the whole country. I also won't dispute that it's disproportionately helping the banks and those rich enough already to be part of the system.
- 11y ago