6 ms·
> reserve deposits are a fraction of lending, not vice-versa. I'm still not sure how that's governments subsidizing them though. Where does the rest of the mon
by pdonis 11y ago
> reserve deposits are a fraction of lending, not vice-versa. I'm still not sure how that's governments subsidizing them though.
Where does the rest of the money that's lent out come from? If you deposit $100 and the bank can, based on that deposit, lend out $1000 (assuming a 10% reserve requirement, which is fairly typical), where does the other $900 come from?
[Edit: this is somewhat misstated, see subthread under jonas21's response.]
- bradleyjg 11y agoThere is a subsidy, but you are putting it in the wrong place in the chain of events. It is the government backstop that is the subsidy, not legalizing the ability to make promises. If you had a banking system with no government backstop you could still have fractional reserve banking but all the players in the system would bear the counterparty risks. The bank could claim you $500 in it but in reality you'd have a contingent interest in the assets of the bank. Money markets worked this way until the USG decided to reward the gamblers by treating them identically to the more prudent.
- pdonis 11y ago> It is the government backstop that is the subsidy, not legalizing the ability to make promises. A bank lending out more money than it actually has on deposit is not just "making promises"; it's "making promises they know they can't keep". Yes, banks did get away with that before the government got into the business of printing money, but it was riskier for them, which is why they prefer to have the government do it--in other words, instead of taking on the risk themselves of printing money not backed by deposits, they prefer to have the government print the money and give it to them to lend. See my response to sbov upthread. The "backstop" is certainly a factor, of course--it's what prevents ordinary bank runs from happening. But, as I noted in my response to sbov upthread, that certainly doesn't eliminate financial panics; it just exchanges one failure mode for another (arguably worse) one. * If you had a banking system with no government backstop you could still have fractional reserve banking but all the players in the system would bear the counterparty risks. The bank could claim you $500 in it but in reality you'd have a contingent interest in the assets of the bank.* Well, I suppose this is true in a technical sense, but the fact is that practically nobody, in the days when banks did this (i.e., before governments started printing the money), understood that this was what was happening. Again, see my response to sbov upthread. > Money markets worked this way until the USG decided to reward the gamblers by treating them identically to the more prudent. I certainly agree that USG's actions have not helped; but "banking" is a much broader category than "money markets", and fractional reserve banking is centuries old. And, as I noted above, practically nobody who deposited money in a bank or borrowed money from one realized what was actually going on; they thought that the bank being "reputable" meant it only lent money it actually had. When people did realize what was actually going on, they started a bank run.
- kbenson 11y ago> it's "making promises they know they can't keep". If that's the case, how do they keep fulfilling those promises? Not fulfilling the promised is the exception, not the norm. You should check your assumptions when they don't align with reality. If you believe any lending when you don't have the full money on hand to account for all the loans is wrong, then you need to apply the same level of scrutiny to borrowing. Borrowing money to do something you didn't have the money to do initially would be just as wrong. The system works because both sides are taking on risk. The borrower's risk (and the risk of everyone using the money( is spread throughout the entire system though.
- pdonis 11y ago> If that's the case, how do they keep fulfilling those promises? By having the government magically conjure new money into existence, and getting everybody to believe that that counts as "fulfilling the promise". And then having to wave their hands and obfuscate when the economy melts down. > If you believe any lending when you don't have the full money on hand to account for all the loans is wrong, then you need to apply the same level of scrutiny to borrowing. What counts as "the same level of scrutiny"? The analogue from the borrower's side would be borrowing money without any intention of paying it back, not borrowing money period. If the borrower takes the money, does something profitable with it, and pays back the loan with interest out of the profits, there's nothing wrong with that; indeed, it's why borrowing exists in the first place: because it's a positive sum transaction, benefiting both sides. > The system works because both sides are taking on risk. A system in which loans were always backed by real wealth would have this property; the lender takes the risk that the borrower won't pay the loan back in full, with interest, and the borrower takes the risk that his business venture won't pan out and he'll have to either find some other way to pay back the loan, with interest, or default and take the penalty for that. But both sides also have the possibility of gain to balance the risk. But our current system forces third parties--the taxpayers--to also take on risk: the risk of having to bail everyone out when the house of cards collapses and the economy melts down. What gain do the taxpayers get in exchange?
- 11y ago
- sbov 11y agoI assume you're trying to imply that it comes from the government. Fractional reserve banking started before central banks, and that extra $900 came from notes the bank printed out, which people would accept as payment for goods and serviced because the bank was reputable. Since most of our money is digital nowadays, it would be even easier than in the past: the major banks could get together and just agree to tick up someone's account by X amount when another bank requests it. No government required.
- pdonis 11y ago> I assume you're trying to imply that it comes from the government. Yes, because that's how our current system works. The government prints money whenever a bank wants to lend it out, regardless of whether additional wealth was created or not. > Fractional reserve banking started before central banks Sure, and in those past systems, individual banks printed money to lend out, regardless of whether additional wealth was created or not. But in our current system, only the government is allowed to do that. Not that that absolves the banks--see below. > which people would accept as payment for goods and serviced because the bank was reputable. Yes. But what does "reputable" mean? What people thought it meant, back in the days when banking was young, was that the bank only lent out wealth that some other depositor had put in. In other words, when you took out a loan from the bank, you believed you were borrowing actual wealth that someone else had made available, and you paid an extra fee (the interest on the loan) for the use of that wealth in some (hopefully) profitable enterprise. The bank, in turn, made a profit as a middleman or broker, hooking up people who had surplus wealth to invest with people who had business enterprises that needed wealth. But then some banks got the bright idea that they could increase their profits by printing more notes than they actually had wealth on deposit, and relying on people's belief that they were "reputable" to get those notes accepted at par--i.e., at the same rate as if they were actually backed by real wealth. If we actually described things as they were, instead of using euphemisms like "fractional reserve banking", the proper name for this would be "fraud". But it also happens to work, as long as one doesn't call it by its right name. Although it does have the downside of creating periodic financial panics, whenever people actually figure out that there isn't enough wealth on deposit at the bank to back all of the notes in circulation, and then they start rushing to the bank to redeem their notes for actual wealth before everyone else does--in other words, a bank run. One of the reasons that banks prefer to have the government do the money printing is that it eliminates this failure mode (in exchange for other worse ones)--see below. > Since most of our money is digital nowadays, it would be even easier than in the past: the major banks could get together and just agree to tick up someone's account by X amount when another bank requests it. No government required. They "could" do that in the sense of it being physically possible, sure. But in fact they don't, because it's illegal. Instead, they got the government to create the Federal Reserve, which does the money printing and allows the banks to maintain plausible deniability. It also has the advantage that, unlike private banks, the government can force people to accept its notes as legal tender, which eliminates the possibility of a bank run in the usual sense (though it certainly does not eliminate financial panics and boom/bust cycles, as we are now all too aware). I'm certainly not saying the banks are blameless in all this; I'm just saying that their current method of transferring wealth to their own pockets requires the government as a middleman.
- kbenson 11y agoThe $900 comes from trust. If I'm a highly respected and wealthy individual in a 18th century village, I could conceivably issue my own notes about my promise to pay the recipient. If someone comes to me for a loan, I could issue a number of these notes to that individual, and anyone else in the village that trusts my ability and likelihood to pay might be willing to take those notes. I have just demonstrated my ability to lend money with no reserve, since I have not demonstrated my finances, people have taken it on reputation and trust. This will work for as long as I'm both mostly restricting my loans to people that will pay back, and not too many people try to redeem the notes at once. This is possible without a government, so the government is not responsible for allowing this, they are putting some restraints on how much of the money I have on hand I can leverage in this manner, so they are regulating it.
- pdonis 11y ago> The $900 comes from trust. Trust of whom? Who prints the money?
- kbenson 11y agoI said "I could issue a number of these notes". It comes of trust in me, or trust in the system of people getting notes from me, as they see the outcomes. There is no difference in printing my own notes than the government printing theirs beyond the trust of the people that it's worth something. That's an intrinsic feature of fiat money. People can lose faith in government currency, there's numerous cases around the world of it happening before. We aren't trading actual physical goods (gold, silver) or notes directly exchangeable for them any more, and haven't been for a long while.
- pdonis 11y ago> I said "I could issue a number of these notes". Not in our current system. Only the government can issue notes; for anyone else to do so is illegal. That was my point. (It's true that, in our current system, most money creation is actually electronic--entries in accounting databases--rather than physical notes. But all of that money creation is still done under rules set down by the government, and denominated in the government's fiat currency. So it's equivalent, for my purposes here, to the government printing notes directly. And nobody can just decide to create, say, a new bank deposit any time they want, or denominate it in their own currency.) > There is no difference in printing my own notes than the government printing theirs beyond the trust of the people that it's worth something. In principle this is, of course, true. But I wasn't arguing that our current system is the only possible fiat money system with fractional reserve banking. I was only arguing that, in our current system as it exists, the government is in fact the only entity allowed to print money (with the qualifications I gave above).
- jonas21 11y agoA 10% reserve requirement would mean that if you deposit $100, then your bank can then lend out $90 of it, not $1000. The money supply has expanded because there is now $190 of things that work like cash out there -- the $100 on my bank account balance plus the $90 that was lent to someone else -- but this is very different from saying the bank can turn around and lend out a multiple of what I have deposited.
- pdonis 11y ago> A 10% reserve requirement would mean that if you deposit $100, then your bank can then lend out $90 of it, not $1000. I misstated it somewhat, yes. The $90 gets lent out--and where does it end up? In someone else's bank deposit. Then $81 of that gets lent out, and ends up--in yet another bank deposit. And so on... At the end of this process, your original deposit has been multiplied by the reciprocal of whatever the reserve requirement is. So a 10% reserve means a multiplier of 1/.01 = 10. So your original deposit of $100 turns into a total of $1000. (So I shouldn't have said that your $100 turns into an additional $1000 lent out--I should have said the total money supply is $1000.) Remember also that, even though $90 of your $100 was lent out, you can still walk into the bank and withdraw the $100 any time; you don't have to wait until whoever borrowed the $90 pays it back. The same is true of all the other deposits spawned by the $90 that is borrowed, and the $81 borrowed against that, and so on... So, again, the final effect of your depositing $100 is that the total money supply is $1000.
- riphay 11y ago> you can still walk into the bank and withdraw the $100 any time This is true, but if everyone did this at once it would constitute a run on the bank and it would fall under its reserve ratio. Not to mention the amount of money in the banking system is far far more than physical currency in print. This is part of why some types of accounts (trading accounts etc.) require a few days to clear transactions. The expansion of the money supply is throughout the banking system and not just cash and deposits.
- pdonis 11y ago
- forgetsusername 11y ago>Where does the rest of the money that's lent out come from? Thin air, and there's nothing special about it. Banks do it, and so do normal people, everyday.
- pdonis 11y ago> so do normal people, everyday Really? Normal people can lend money they don't actually have? How does that work? If you mean that normal people can create wealth, of course they can. But that's not what we're talking about here.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>How does that work? They create liabilities; IOUs. Just like you can. And there's no limit to how many you are allowed to create, beyond your creditworthiness in the eyes of the party to the exchange.
- pdonis 11y ago> They create liabilities; IOUs. Suppose I give you an IOU for $100. Can you go and buy groceries with it? Or even more to the point, can you pay your taxes with it?
- forgetsusername 11y agoThat depends on whether the party to my transaction accepts your IOU. Most likely, they would not. But they would accept the IOUs of the FRB. That's why we use them. There's nothing special about dollars, except that they are widely accepted in exchange and accepted by the government by mandate.
- pdonis 11y ago> That depends on whether the party to my transaction accepts your IOU. Most likely, they would not. Correct. They have a choice about whether to accept your IOU or not (and, as you say, they will most likely choose not to). You have no way to force them to. (In the case of paying taxes, the other party is the government, and they definitely won't accept your IOU; you have to pay your taxes in the government's fiat currency.) > they would accept the IOUs of the FRB Because they don't have a choice; by law everyone has to accept Federal Reserve Notes (I use that term because I don't agree with using the term "IOU" to refer to them, for reasons which I have argued in other subthreads and don't want to rehash here) as legal tender. And the government can back up that law with legitimate force, because it's the government. That's why having a system where the government prints money is different from a system where private entities print money.