3 ms·
In theory you are right. In reality thats just not how they make their money. Amongst other reasons because the governments have deemed them too important for n
by ThomPete 11y ago
In theory you are right. In reality thats just not how they make their money. Amongst other reasons because the governments have deemed them too important for normal people and so they in effect subsidize them and fund them through amongst other things Fractional Reserve Banking.
The big banks are considered too big to fail and so they more less have a get out of jail card to gear their risk. The money they can make from personal savings accounts are absurdly insignificant compared to these other areas.
- kbenson 11y ago> governments have deemed them too important for normal people and so they in effect subsidize them and fund them through amongst other things Fractional Reserve Banking. Isn't Fractional Reserve Banking where banks are required to keep a portion of the deposits available as a reserve in case their investments go bad? How is that governments subsidizing them? Without fractional reserve, banks would be free to lend out as much of your deposited money as they thought they could get away with. Edit: Ah, from reading some more it appears it's different in a few very important details, even if the structure is the same. The Banks are only allowed to lend a certain multiple of the cash reserves they have on hand, not a certain fraction. That is, reserve deposits are a fraction of lending, not vice-versa. I'm still not sure how that's governments subsidizing them though. Without the restriction on lending, I could see banks getting a little wild in the boom economies (which happened in the mid to late 2000s).
- pdonis 11y ago> reserve deposits are a fraction of lending, not vice-versa. I'm still not sure how that's governments subsidizing them though. Where does the rest of the money that's lent out come from? If you deposit $100 and the bank can, based on that deposit, lend out $1000 (assuming a 10% reserve requirement, which is fairly typical), where does the other $900 come from? [Edit: this is somewhat misstated, see subthread under jonas21's response.]
- bradleyjg 11y agoThere is a subsidy, but you are putting it in the wrong place in the chain of events. It is the government backstop that is the subsidy, not legalizing the ability to make promises. If you had a banking system with no government backstop you could still have fractional reserve banking but all the players in the system would bear the counterparty risks. The bank could claim you $500 in it but in reality you'd have a contingent interest in the assets of the bank. Money markets worked this way until the USG decided to reward the gamblers by treating them identically to the more prudent.
- pdonis 11y ago> It is the government backstop that is the subsidy, not legalizing the ability to make promises. A bank lending out more money than it actually has on deposit is not just "making promises"; it's "making promises they know they can't keep". Yes, banks did get away with that before the government got into the business of printing money, but it was riskier for them, which is why they prefer to have the government do it--in other words, instead of taking on the risk themselves of printing money not backed by deposits, they prefer to have the government print the money and give it to them to lend. See my response to sbov upthread. The "backstop" is certainly a factor, of course--it's what prevents ordinary bank runs from happening. But, as I noted in my response to sbov upthread, that certainly doesn't eliminate financial panics; it just exchanges one failure mode for another (arguably worse) one. * If you had a banking system with no government backstop you could still have fractional reserve banking but all the players in the system would bear the counterparty risks. The bank could claim you $500 in it but in reality you'd have a contingent interest in the assets of the bank.* Well, I suppose this is true in a technical sense, but the fact is that practically nobody, in the days when banks did this (i.e., before governments started printing the money), understood that this was what was happening. Again, see my response to sbov upthread. > Money markets worked this way until the USG decided to reward the gamblers by treating them identically to the more prudent. I certainly agree that USG's actions have not helped; but "banking" is a much broader category than "money markets", and fractional reserve banking is centuries old. And, as I noted above, practically nobody who deposited money in a bank or borrowed money from one realized what was actually going on; they thought that the bank being "reputable" meant it only lent money it actually had. When people did realize what was actually going on, they started a bank run.
- stretchwithme 11y ago"reserve deposits are a fraction of lending, not vice-versa" It amazes me how many people get that backwards. If a bank could loan more money than had on deposit, they could could simply loan themselves or other banks enough to pay off depositors. That is literally a license to print money. And the government prefers to keep that power for themselves. That's what the Federal Reserve is. For every deposit of $10, they might earn 2% on the $9 they are allowed to lend out. They have to live on that 18 cents. If they were able to loan out $90 or $100 (depending on what theory you hear), they'd make 10 times as much. Within a decade, they wouldn't need their deposits. But banks do fail, so clearly that is not the case. I think people are confusing modern banks with ancient banks that took in gold deposits and issued paper notes based on those deposits, sometimes issuing more notes than the gold they had on deposit. That is a completely different situation. And was not sustainable when it did occur. The banking system is a huge creator of bubbles, but it does not work the way many imagine. I asked one believer in the multiplier theory to show me the statute that says it works that way. He found the law that contradicted his belief and insisted it proved it.
- ThomPete 11y agoWhen banks lend someone money via FRB they aren't moving money from one account to another to make them available on the loaners account. They are literally making the money appear without it afecting any other account in the system. Banks can loan more out than they have in the bank but it's relative to how much they have in the bank they can loan out. It's the central banks who "vouch" for this mechanism and is why banks are said to be able to "print" money out of no-where I guess.
- stretchwithme 11y agoMay I ask why you think that is the case?
- ThomPete 11y ago"Because bank deposits are usually considered money in their own right, and because banks hold reserves that are less than their deposit liabilities, fractional-reserve banking permits the money supply to grow beyond the amount of the underlying reserves of base money originally created by the central bank.[1][3] In most countries, the central bank (or other monetary authority) regulates bank credit creation, imposing reserve requirements and capital adequacy ratios. This can limit the amount of money creation that occurs in the commercial banking system, and helps to ensure that banks are solvent and have enough funds to meet demand for withdrawals.[3]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking The point about Fractional reserve banking is to allow banks to create debt which is another way to create money. (Debt is money) This is actually what a lot of people are missing. It's not money thats being created per se but debt (credit) which is the same thing but just in put in a different context.
- pas 11y agoBasel III is the new risk limit framework. Banks have become critical infrastructure. They are not subsidized nor funded by the Federal Reserve System (the Fed) in any way. The (fractional) reserve requirement is not really relevant, because any bank can just borrow cash (discount window policy), put it into their reserve account - and presto, - lend out more. So if they want to lend out X, they have to borrow X+(0.05 * X). But the reserve requirement and the discount window are not the main monetary policy tools, because it's usually not cost effective to borrow from the Fed. However, it's even easier than that. Not all liabilities are (fractionally) backed by reserves, so if a bank can shuffle the money from one type to an other, it can lend out more of that. ( https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/epr/02v08n1/0205bennpdf.pdf https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/epr/0... ) https://www.richmondfed.org/~/media/richmondfedorg/publications/research/region_focus/2011/q1/pdf/federal_reserve.pdf https://www.richmondfed.org/~/media/richmondfedorg/publicati... - graph on the 3rd page is worth looking at All in all, banks are risk constrained. The growth rate of the money supply is basically a measure of how lenders think the economy will grow (how much new wealth will be created), since debt that gets paid back shrinks the money supply (assuming constant velocity of money, if the velocity increases, less money is sufficient to sustain the debt cycle). Personal savings accounts are important, because they get access to cheap capital, so they don't have to raise it elsewhere in order to lend it out. Effectively, banks are a strange, misaligned, mismanaged and misregulated amalgamation of a completely automatic thing [money management, transactions, deposits, ATMs] and (investment) risk assessment. Those should be separated, or the interfaces made clear. (Such as you get a better credit rating if you grant access to your account event history/stream. And we should forget about using savings deposits and other accounts as sources for lending.)